There's lots of evidence that the defendant was acting crazy at the time of the offense. Indeed, that he was crazy. He was behaving weirdly at a senior housing complex in Oakland, and was trying to climb the exterior of the building as well as running around the parking lot "crashing his head into cars and garbage cans." He saw a random woman and asked her to give him a kiss, and then grabbed her and bit her multiple times. When the police came, he was mumbling and running around between two cars. The police used a taser on him several times, and when the officer threatened to use the taser again, the defendant said "Tase me!" Defendant was eventually handcuffed after a struggle, and went to trial for his crimes.
This would well have been the result of psychosis. Whether drug-induced or not; the defendant has a history of polysubstance abuse, but he was also shot in the head and had a traumatic brain injury when he was 17.
Whatever. The jury found him guilty, but then not guilty by reason of insanity.
That verdict makes sense. I understand it. The guy was apparently so out of it that he couldn't tell right from wrong. Or at least that's what the jury concluded.
That part I get.
But that's not what today's opinion is about. The Court of Appeal holds that the conviction has to be reversed because the jury wasn't instructed that it's a substantive defense to criminality that at the time of the offense you were unconscious, and that there was substantial evidence here that the defendant was unconscious.
Whoa. That's a little weird.
Justice Ruvolo's opinion does a very good job explaining the evolution of the jurisprudence of "unconsciousness" and its interaction with sanity determinations. What we normally think of when we talk about someone being "unconscious" isn't necessarily the same as what we mean by that term in criminal law.
Okay. I get it. We're using this term in a broader sense.
But even after reading the entire opinion a couple of times, I'm still not at all sure of the dividing line between "unconscious" and "insane" under the Court of Appeal's approach.
I get that when you're sleepwalking, you're "unconscious" even though you might be moving and appear to have voluntary control. Ditto for when you're in the midst of an epileptic seizure. Or when you've had a severe blow to the head. You might look like you're in control, but you're not.
But for people with, say, paranoid schizophrenia, or with the kind of mental disorder that defendant her might have had, I'm not sure how one tells the difference between "just" being insane -- a status that means you're found guilty but are placed in a hospital -- and being "unconscious" and hence are entirely relieved of all punishment/treatment.
It seems to me that the Court of Appeal is saying something like when you're "really" insane, you may have no voluntary/volitional control over your actions. Or at least no "rational" control. I get that. It resonates with me. But I'm not sure that I then understand what the difference is between being insane and being unconscious. If you're so "insane" that the "crazy" part of your brain is the one that's taking control, then it seems like you're always (or nearly always) "unconscious" too, at least under the Court of Appeal's interpretation. Or, at a minimum, I'm not at all sure how a jury is supposed to determine the difference -- and I feel confident that whatever jury instructions we try to come up for this one won't explain things well at all, especially since the Court of Appeal can't seem to explain the difference well even to (relatively) sophisticated non-laypeople like me.
Maybe there's a clear dividing line here. I just don't see it. Justice Ruvolo's intuition doesn't seem entirely wrong. I'm just not sure were "insane" ends and "unconsciousness" begins. At all. Despite the fact that there's tons that's riding on that distinction; i.e., being found guilty but insane versus not being found guilty at all.
I understand that this is a tough issue. I understand that concepts are evolving. I understand that there might be some potential overlap. I understand that there might be a serious problem here.
I'm just not certain precisely where the Court of Appeal is drawing the line. Or whether the resulting line makes sense.
Thoughts on recent Ninth Circuit and California appellate cases from Professor Shaun Martin at the University of San Diego School of Law.
Tuesday, July 14, 2015
Monday, July 13, 2015
DKN Holdings, Inc. v. Faerber (Cal. Supreme Ct. - July 13, 2015)
Today's opinion from the California Supreme Court sounds exactly like what I would say to one of my first-year law students who was confused about res judicata.
Justice Corrigan's opinion is careful, patient and slow. She essentially says: "Look, I understand that this stuff is confusing. The terms are in Latin, and sometimes even smart people (e.g., us) use the phrase 'res judicata' to describe two different things. So I can understand why you might well find this difficult. But you're allowed to sue two different parties in two different lawsuits. The second suit isn't barred by what's properly called 'claim preclusion'. Even if there's joint and several liability. Even if you could potentially sue them both in a single lawsuit. It's just not required. Your call whether you want to file one lawsuit or two."
There's a reason today's opinion is unanimous. Because that's clearly a correct statement of the law.
Even if the trial court, and the Court of Appeal, below got it wrong. Like many, many law students before them.
Justice Corrigan's opinion is careful, patient and slow. She essentially says: "Look, I understand that this stuff is confusing. The terms are in Latin, and sometimes even smart people (e.g., us) use the phrase 'res judicata' to describe two different things. So I can understand why you might well find this difficult. But you're allowed to sue two different parties in two different lawsuits. The second suit isn't barred by what's properly called 'claim preclusion'. Even if there's joint and several liability. Even if you could potentially sue them both in a single lawsuit. It's just not required. Your call whether you want to file one lawsuit or two."
There's a reason today's opinion is unanimous. Because that's clearly a correct statement of the law.
Even if the trial court, and the Court of Appeal, below got it wrong. Like many, many law students before them.
Friday, July 10, 2015
California Dep't of Corr. & Rehab. v. CSPB (Cal. Ct. App. - July 10, 2015)
It's not only criminals who get benefits from technicalities:
"Appellant Joseph McCauley (McCauley) was promoted to the position of Correctional Sergeant at Avenal State Prison by his employer, the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR). The new position began on December 2, 2008, and was subject to a 12-month probationary period before it became permanent. On December 1, 2009, CDCR served a notice of rejection on McCauley to remove him from the position of Correctional Sergeant effective on December 8, 2009. On December 2, 2009, another document was served on McCauley, this one purporting to extend his probationary period until December 8, 2009. McCauley maintained that CDCR’s notice of rejection and other papers were invalid due to failure to comply with certain timing and notice requirements relating directly to the duration of the probationary period. . . .
We hold that McCauley is correct that the notice of rejection was fatally deficient under applicable law because the effective date of the rejection (i.e., Dec. 8, 2009) was after the completion of his probationary period."
"Appellant Joseph McCauley (McCauley) was promoted to the position of Correctional Sergeant at Avenal State Prison by his employer, the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR). The new position began on December 2, 2008, and was subject to a 12-month probationary period before it became permanent. On December 1, 2009, CDCR served a notice of rejection on McCauley to remove him from the position of Correctional Sergeant effective on December 8, 2009. On December 2, 2009, another document was served on McCauley, this one purporting to extend his probationary period until December 8, 2009. McCauley maintained that CDCR’s notice of rejection and other papers were invalid due to failure to comply with certain timing and notice requirements relating directly to the duration of the probationary period. . . .
We hold that McCauley is correct that the notice of rejection was fatally deficient under applicable law because the effective date of the rejection (i.e., Dec. 8, 2009) was after the completion of his probationary period."
Thursday, July 09, 2015
Olive v. CIR (9th Cir. - July 9, 2015)
You might well be able to do something under state law. For example: Sell marijuana.
But you can't beat the Tax Man.
The Ninth Circuit holds this morning that if you're a medical marijuana dispensary, you can't deduct any business expenses. That's right: any. Not even the ones you legitimately incurred.
Did Congress have this result in mind when it passed the relevant tax statute? Perhaps not. But that statute is nonetheless clear. It says that a taxpayer can't deduct any expenses if the relevant "trade or business . . . consists of trafficking in controlled substances . . . prohibited by Federal law."
For better or worse, that's on point to what a marijuana dispensary does. Because, as a reminder, marijuana remains illegal -- e.g., a controlled substance -- under federal law.
Martin Olive has a couple of legal arguments as to why the statute shouldn't apply. But as the panel correctly holds, they're not persuasive. The statute means what it says. You can still operate a marijuana dispensary if you want. But you're going to have to pay taxes on your gross profit, not your net.
Which isn't going to be very much fun.
But you can't beat the Tax Man.
The Ninth Circuit holds this morning that if you're a medical marijuana dispensary, you can't deduct any business expenses. That's right: any. Not even the ones you legitimately incurred.
Did Congress have this result in mind when it passed the relevant tax statute? Perhaps not. But that statute is nonetheless clear. It says that a taxpayer can't deduct any expenses if the relevant "trade or business . . . consists of trafficking in controlled substances . . . prohibited by Federal law."
For better or worse, that's on point to what a marijuana dispensary does. Because, as a reminder, marijuana remains illegal -- e.g., a controlled substance -- under federal law.
Martin Olive has a couple of legal arguments as to why the statute shouldn't apply. But as the panel correctly holds, they're not persuasive. The statute means what it says. You can still operate a marijuana dispensary if you want. But you're going to have to pay taxes on your gross profit, not your net.
Which isn't going to be very much fun.
Wednesday, July 08, 2015
Altafulla v. Ervin (Cal. Ct. App. - July 7, 2015)
It's not that I don't like published opinions. I do. A lot. The more reasoned precedent the better, I figure.
It's also not like this opinion isn't worthy of publication. It is. Justice Benke says a lot in her opinion that's worth saying. And worth letting everyone know. Like the fact that an email campaign against a domestic partner, especially when combined with an apparent attempt to traumatize her children, can properly give rise to a domestic violence protective order. As well as the fact that it's not necessarily a valid defense to such an order to say that the things you were saying as part of those campaigns were true.
All that's worth mentioning.
The problem is this: There's a lot -- and I mean, a lot -- of detail in the opinion.
Now, normally, that's a good thing. But here, when I say "detail", I also mean "dirt". We learn from this published opinion that the victim here essentially admitted to having an affair. We learn who the affair was probably with: "someone associated with a client of her employer." We learn not only that there appear to be pictures of the affair and a surveillance report, but also that the affair may have involved "oral copulation". We learn that when the perpetrator described in excruciating detail what a "blowjob" entailed to the victim's daughters -- one of whom was nine years old -- and the perpetrator's belief that there was "a risk they could contract sexually transmitted diseases from towels their mother might use," the elder daughter was so traumatized that she required inpatient care at a mental health facility. We even learn that following one of the trips she took with her lover, the victim experienced a yeast infection.
There's a reason, of course, that Justice Benke includes all of these details in the opinion. They provide not only color, but they're relevant to the legal claims at issue in the appeal.
So I'm not critiquing their inclusion.
But the thing is: the opinion uses the victim's real name. Not her initials. Not "Carolina A." or something like that. Her full, complete name.
And it's not a common one. There's exactly one person in the entire United States with that name. And the fact that we know that she lives in San Diego -- and all the other details about her in the opinion -- make it crystal clear who she is.
Which means we know not only all the gory details about her personal life that are in the opinion, but can take a gander at her Twitter posts, find out where she works from her LinkedIn page, and even check out the stuff she likes on Pinterest.
Remember: We're talking about the victim here.
It's bad enough to include her name in an "unpublished" -- but still available -- opinion. But to include it in a published opinion, for all posterity? I think that's bad form. She was victimized enough by having her former domestic partner e-mail her employer and their mutual friends and letting them all know the sordid details. If there's anything she doesn't need, I imagine, it's to have those same details disseminated to the remainder of the universe.
Now, admittedly, it doesn't appear that the victim ever attempted to get the matter sealed, or to truncate her name. But she also didn't necessarily know that the opinion would be (1) published, and (2) feel the need to disclose every dirty little secret that might potentially be relevant to the disposition. It also bears mention that it wasn't the victim who requested publication: it was the Association of Certified Family Law Specialists.
Particularly given what gave rise to the underlying protective order -- e.g., the public dissemination of private facts about a victim -- I think that Justice Benke's opinion could be improved with a simple change. Get rid of the full name. Leave some tiny shred of anonymity for cases like this. And make sure that when future employers Google the victim's name, the first thing they see isn't an opinion that contains intimate details like her affair, her yeast infection, and her particular (alleged) sexual practices.
P.S. - FWIW, I don't feel the same about the perpetrator and appellant, John Ervin. Particularly given the number of lawsuits to which he's a party (feel free to do an internet search for a sample of those), I think his anonymity is pretty much out the window at this point.
It's also not like this opinion isn't worthy of publication. It is. Justice Benke says a lot in her opinion that's worth saying. And worth letting everyone know. Like the fact that an email campaign against a domestic partner, especially when combined with an apparent attempt to traumatize her children, can properly give rise to a domestic violence protective order. As well as the fact that it's not necessarily a valid defense to such an order to say that the things you were saying as part of those campaigns were true.
All that's worth mentioning.
The problem is this: There's a lot -- and I mean, a lot -- of detail in the opinion.
Now, normally, that's a good thing. But here, when I say "detail", I also mean "dirt". We learn from this published opinion that the victim here essentially admitted to having an affair. We learn who the affair was probably with: "someone associated with a client of her employer." We learn not only that there appear to be pictures of the affair and a surveillance report, but also that the affair may have involved "oral copulation". We learn that when the perpetrator described in excruciating detail what a "blowjob" entailed to the victim's daughters -- one of whom was nine years old -- and the perpetrator's belief that there was "a risk they could contract sexually transmitted diseases from towels their mother might use," the elder daughter was so traumatized that she required inpatient care at a mental health facility. We even learn that following one of the trips she took with her lover, the victim experienced a yeast infection.
There's a reason, of course, that Justice Benke includes all of these details in the opinion. They provide not only color, but they're relevant to the legal claims at issue in the appeal.
So I'm not critiquing their inclusion.
But the thing is: the opinion uses the victim's real name. Not her initials. Not "Carolina A." or something like that. Her full, complete name.
And it's not a common one. There's exactly one person in the entire United States with that name. And the fact that we know that she lives in San Diego -- and all the other details about her in the opinion -- make it crystal clear who she is.
Which means we know not only all the gory details about her personal life that are in the opinion, but can take a gander at her Twitter posts, find out where she works from her LinkedIn page, and even check out the stuff she likes on Pinterest.
Remember: We're talking about the victim here.
It's bad enough to include her name in an "unpublished" -- but still available -- opinion. But to include it in a published opinion, for all posterity? I think that's bad form. She was victimized enough by having her former domestic partner e-mail her employer and their mutual friends and letting them all know the sordid details. If there's anything she doesn't need, I imagine, it's to have those same details disseminated to the remainder of the universe.
Now, admittedly, it doesn't appear that the victim ever attempted to get the matter sealed, or to truncate her name. But she also didn't necessarily know that the opinion would be (1) published, and (2) feel the need to disclose every dirty little secret that might potentially be relevant to the disposition. It also bears mention that it wasn't the victim who requested publication: it was the Association of Certified Family Law Specialists.
Particularly given what gave rise to the underlying protective order -- e.g., the public dissemination of private facts about a victim -- I think that Justice Benke's opinion could be improved with a simple change. Get rid of the full name. Leave some tiny shred of anonymity for cases like this. And make sure that when future employers Google the victim's name, the first thing they see isn't an opinion that contains intimate details like her affair, her yeast infection, and her particular (alleged) sexual practices.
P.S. - FWIW, I don't feel the same about the perpetrator and appellant, John Ervin. Particularly given the number of lawsuits to which he's a party (feel free to do an internet search for a sample of those), I think his anonymity is pretty much out the window at this point.
Tuesday, July 07, 2015
U.S. ex rel. Hartpence v. Kinetic Concepts (9th Cir. - July 7, 2015)
"Wrong!"
That's what an en banc court of the Ninth Circuit unanimously says today about a prior circuit precedent.
The prior case, Wang v. FMC Corp., held that a qui tam relator had to have played a role in a prior public disclosure of fraud before he could file a lawsuit under the False Claims Act. But the Ninth Circuit now says that this decision was wrong. Wrongly decided then. Wrong rule now. Overruled.
"We hold today that there are two, and only two, requirements in order for a whistleblower to be an 'original source' who may recover under the False Claims Act: (1) Before filing his action, the whistleblower must voluntarily inform the government of the facts which underlie the allegations of his complaint; and (2) he must have direct and independent knowledge of the allegations underlying his complaint. Abrogating our earlier precedent, we conclude that it does not matter whether he also played a role in the public disclosure of the allegations that are part of his suit."
The prior opinion was authored by Judge Poole, and joined by Judges Betty Fletcher and T.G. Nelson. Serendipitously, one of the members of the en banc panel is Judge William Fletcher. So this is one of those rare occasions when a judge gets to tell everyone, for posterity, that his mother was wrong.
One other, tiny, error. Judge Bea's en banc opinion says that "Wang has been the law of this circuit for 23 years." Not quite. It's actually 22 years, since Wang was decided in September of 1992.
But I'll go ahead and let the court round. Good enough for government work.
That's what an en banc court of the Ninth Circuit unanimously says today about a prior circuit precedent.
The prior case, Wang v. FMC Corp., held that a qui tam relator had to have played a role in a prior public disclosure of fraud before he could file a lawsuit under the False Claims Act. But the Ninth Circuit now says that this decision was wrong. Wrongly decided then. Wrong rule now. Overruled.
"We hold today that there are two, and only two, requirements in order for a whistleblower to be an 'original source' who may recover under the False Claims Act: (1) Before filing his action, the whistleblower must voluntarily inform the government of the facts which underlie the allegations of his complaint; and (2) he must have direct and independent knowledge of the allegations underlying his complaint. Abrogating our earlier precedent, we conclude that it does not matter whether he also played a role in the public disclosure of the allegations that are part of his suit."
The prior opinion was authored by Judge Poole, and joined by Judges Betty Fletcher and T.G. Nelson. Serendipitously, one of the members of the en banc panel is Judge William Fletcher. So this is one of those rare occasions when a judge gets to tell everyone, for posterity, that his mother was wrong.
One other, tiny, error. Judge Bea's en banc opinion says that "Wang has been the law of this circuit for 23 years." Not quite. It's actually 22 years, since Wang was decided in September of 1992.
But I'll go ahead and let the court round. Good enough for government work.
Monday, July 06, 2015
Meridian Joint School Dist. No. 2 v. D.A. (9th Cir. - July 6, 2015)
Here's a weird one. At least to an outsider like me.
Among other things, the Ninth Circuit vacates and injunction that prohibited a high school student from graduating. That part doesn't seem strange. Judge Callahan's opinion on that point seems spot on to me.
The somewhat bizarre thing is that the injunction was sought by the kid's parents. They wanted the Ninth Circuit to affirm the injunction, even though their child had completed all of the requirements for graduation and he was now three years out of high school.
Reading an earlier portion of the opinion, which recounts that the (then-) child had set fire to a room of the family home when he was a freshman, you might think that the parents were perhaps trying to get back at the kid.
Nope. They just wanted an injunction so the kid wouldn't graduate high school so the school district would have to give him additional services as a disabled child.
No dice, however. Injunction gets lifted. And the parents (and their counsel) don't get paid the vast majority of the attorney's fees they've run up in this incredibly long-running IDEA saga.
Among other things, the Ninth Circuit vacates and injunction that prohibited a high school student from graduating. That part doesn't seem strange. Judge Callahan's opinion on that point seems spot on to me.
The somewhat bizarre thing is that the injunction was sought by the kid's parents. They wanted the Ninth Circuit to affirm the injunction, even though their child had completed all of the requirements for graduation and he was now three years out of high school.
Reading an earlier portion of the opinion, which recounts that the (then-) child had set fire to a room of the family home when he was a freshman, you might think that the parents were perhaps trying to get back at the kid.
Nope. They just wanted an injunction so the kid wouldn't graduate high school so the school district would have to give him additional services as a disabled child.
No dice, however. Injunction gets lifted. And the parents (and their counsel) don't get paid the vast majority of the attorney's fees they've run up in this incredibly long-running IDEA saga.
Friday, July 03, 2015
People v. Vukodinovich (Cal. Ct. App. - June 29, 2015)
It's the day before July 4. So everyone's on holiday. (Except for most lawyers, of course.) Which means no new opinions.
But as we head into the holiday, let's just send a simple message. You'd think that you wouldn't have to remind anyone of this. But apparently it's worth making clear:
If you're a 73-year old bus driver, and on your bus is a disabled, partially blind person with an IQ of 37 and a mental age of three or four, don't have repeatedly have sex with her. Or even do it once.
Otherwise you'll spend 14 years in prison. Which, since you're 73, is likely for the rest of your life.
Happy Fourth of July.
But as we head into the holiday, let's just send a simple message. You'd think that you wouldn't have to remind anyone of this. But apparently it's worth making clear:
If you're a 73-year old bus driver, and on your bus is a disabled, partially blind person with an IQ of 37 and a mental age of three or four, don't have repeatedly have sex with her. Or even do it once.
Otherwise you'll spend 14 years in prison. Which, since you're 73, is likely for the rest of your life.
Happy Fourth of July.
Thursday, July 02, 2015
Valley Crest Landscape Development, inc. v. Mission Pools (Cal. Ct. App. - July 2, 2015)
How much do you think this fact pattern settles for:
"The St. Regis is a resort facility located in Dana Point and is owned by CPH Monarch Hotel, LLC (CPH). . . . On September 15, 2007, Epp dived into the shallow end of one the swimming pools at the St. Regis. Epp, who was intoxicated at the time, seriously injured his spine and was rendered a quadriplegic. . . .
[Plaintiffs] identified the following defects as allegedly contributing to their injuries: (1) “[t]he vertical tile depth markers were partially submerged, making them illegible”; (2) “faded deck top depth markers”; (3) “[p]oor contrast on the signs containing ‘No Diving’ warning”; (4) “[p]oor location of signs”; (5) “[l]ack of fence between pools so users were not directed to entrance near ‘No Diving’ sign”; (6) “[f]ailure of hotel to enforce its rule directing users to not use pool after alcohol intake”; and (7) use of colored (French gray) plaster for the swimming pool."
The injuries are, of course, severe. From what the plaintiffs have alleged, does this sound like a strong case or a weak case? A $20 million case? $20,000? Some (particular) number in between?
The case settles for $4.5 million.
Based upon the allegations, that's not the number I would have guessed.
"The St. Regis is a resort facility located in Dana Point and is owned by CPH Monarch Hotel, LLC (CPH). . . . On September 15, 2007, Epp dived into the shallow end of one the swimming pools at the St. Regis. Epp, who was intoxicated at the time, seriously injured his spine and was rendered a quadriplegic. . . .
[Plaintiffs] identified the following defects as allegedly contributing to their injuries: (1) “[t]he vertical tile depth markers were partially submerged, making them illegible”; (2) “faded deck top depth markers”; (3) “[p]oor contrast on the signs containing ‘No Diving’ warning”; (4) “[p]oor location of signs”; (5) “[l]ack of fence between pools so users were not directed to entrance near ‘No Diving’ sign”; (6) “[f]ailure of hotel to enforce its rule directing users to not use pool after alcohol intake”; and (7) use of colored (French gray) plaster for the swimming pool."
The injuries are, of course, severe. From what the plaintiffs have alleged, does this sound like a strong case or a weak case? A $20 million case? $20,000? Some (particular) number in between?
The case settles for $4.5 million.
Based upon the allegations, that's not the number I would have guessed.
Wednesday, July 01, 2015
Santos v. Brown (Cal. Ct. App. - July 1, 2015)
The Court of Appeal publishes this opinion today. And it's relentless. Relentless. Seriously. Relentless.
Justice Hull lets you know at the very outset that we're not just talking about any defendant. He lets you know in the very first sentence not only who we're talking about and what he did, but also why this is a high-profile case. Saying: "Esteban Nunez -- the son of Fabian Nunez, the former Speaker of the California State Assembly -- aided in the killing of Luis Santos, the only son of Frederico and Kathy Santos, during a knife attack on October 4, 2008."
Now, that doesn't necessarily tell you if the Court of Appeal is going to go hard or soft on this one. Maybe they're going to take a good look at the case and have sympathy for a troubled young man, despite the fact that we're usually pretty harsh on criminal defendants.
But you quickly get a sense that that's not necessarily how things are going to go down. Because then Justice Hull tells the reader -- in the very next sentences -- why Mr. Nunez was convicted:
"The attack, initiated by Esteban Nunez and his acquaintances on Santos and on other young men, none of whom were armed, took place near the campus of San Diego State University. Among other acts of violence, one of Esteban Nunez’s cohorts stabbed Luis Santos in the chest severing an artery in his heart after which Luis Santos almost immediately bled to death. During the fight Esteban Nunez stabbed another young man in the abdomen and in the back and stabbed a third young man in the shoulder. We set forth the facts surrounding the knife attack by Esteban Nunez and the others in more detail in a moment."
Well, now. That's not very good, is it? Maybe the Court of Appeal's not going to look so favorably on this young man after all. Sounds like his conviction's going to be affirmed, right?
But this case isn't about his conviction. It's about something else. Because Mr. Nunez pled guilty to voluntary manslaughter, and "[i]n June 2010, he was sentenced to serve 16 years in prison."
So what's it about? You may perhaps recall the details. If not, Justice Hull reminds you of just what transpired thereafter:
"On January 2, 2011, his last day in office as Governor of California, Arnold Schwarzenegger exercised his executive clemency power . . . by commuting (reducing) the prison sentence of Esteban Nunez from 16 years to seven years."
Then Justice Hull adds a paragraph break. After noting the "midnight" nature of the clemency, he adds:
"The commutation came as a complete surprise to the crime victims and the prosecuting district attorney."
Hmm. I wonder how Justice Hull feels about Gov. Schwarzenegger's decision?
One need not speculate. Justice Hull tells the reader exactly what he thinks: "We are compelled to conclude that, while Schwarzenegger’s conduct could be seen as deserving of censure and grossly unjust, it was not illegal. Marsy’s Law [which requires advance notification to victims parole and related proceedings], despite its obviously expansive protection of victims’ rights does not restrict the executive’s clemency powers under California Constitution, article V, section 8, subdivision (a) or the clemency statutes, and we must affirm the judgment."
"Deserving of censure" and "grossly unjust". Tell us what you really think, Justice Hull.
The Governator isn't the only one who's at the receiving end of the Court of Appeal's ire. Mr. Nunez doesn't get treated with kid gloves either. A brief sample of the Court of Appeal's opinion is more than enough to let you know what the justices think of him as well:
"Esteban Nunez’s self-serving letter to the court asserted he felt remorse, not for what he did, but for what “happened.” He blamed his codefendants for having “negative influences” on him. He claimed he “always intended to take responsibility for my actions” (despite fleeing the scene and destroying evidence) and was willing to turn himself in when the arrest warrant issued, but the district attorney was not interested. He said, “the justice system has its faults,” but “I still have hope the truth will be seen and heard. I guess I’m asking that you pay attention to the facts on this case, for the facts speak for themselves.”
Contrary to the content and tone of Nunez’s letter, the probation report states Nunez lied when first contacted by police, was “never cooperative,” and after his arrest and release sent a text message to a codefendant stating, 'Gangster rap made us do it lol.'"
Dude. After you've stabbed someone, and someone's been killed, it's probably not a good idea to send a mocking text message to your co-defendant. That tends to make you look, oh, I don't know: kinda bad.
Oh, and lest you think that the Court of Appeal is only displeased about the result, they've got some words about the process as well. Saying:
"On January 2, 2011, Schwarzenegger’s last day as Governor, he announced in an executive order signed on December 31, 2010, he had commuted Nunez’s sentence from 16 years to seven years. Back-room dealings were apparent. Esteban had filed a notice of appeal in the criminal case but signed a notice of abandonment and request for dismissal of appeal on December 6, 2010 -- before the grant of clemency. Nunez’s attorney signed the abandonment and dismissal request the day after the grant of clemency and filed it later, on January 20, 2011. Neither the victims nor the district attorney were notified that Schwarzenegger was considering commuting Nunez’s sentence."
In short, Mr. Nunez (and Gov. Schwarzenegger) essentially win the appeal, but get tarred in the process. Not that they perhaps care. But tarred they are. Mercilessly.
The Court of Appeal's opinion is unanimous. Both Justice Raye and Justice Murray, however, also write concurring opinions. The last paragraph of Justice Murray's concurrence begins: "As reprehensible as the Governor’s action in this instance might have been . . . ."
Lest there be any doubt from Justice Hull's opinion what the panel thinks.
Justice Hull lets you know at the very outset that we're not just talking about any defendant. He lets you know in the very first sentence not only who we're talking about and what he did, but also why this is a high-profile case. Saying: "Esteban Nunez -- the son of Fabian Nunez, the former Speaker of the California State Assembly -- aided in the killing of Luis Santos, the only son of Frederico and Kathy Santos, during a knife attack on October 4, 2008."
Now, that doesn't necessarily tell you if the Court of Appeal is going to go hard or soft on this one. Maybe they're going to take a good look at the case and have sympathy for a troubled young man, despite the fact that we're usually pretty harsh on criminal defendants.
But you quickly get a sense that that's not necessarily how things are going to go down. Because then Justice Hull tells the reader -- in the very next sentences -- why Mr. Nunez was convicted:
"The attack, initiated by Esteban Nunez and his acquaintances on Santos and on other young men, none of whom were armed, took place near the campus of San Diego State University. Among other acts of violence, one of Esteban Nunez’s cohorts stabbed Luis Santos in the chest severing an artery in his heart after which Luis Santos almost immediately bled to death. During the fight Esteban Nunez stabbed another young man in the abdomen and in the back and stabbed a third young man in the shoulder. We set forth the facts surrounding the knife attack by Esteban Nunez and the others in more detail in a moment."
Well, now. That's not very good, is it? Maybe the Court of Appeal's not going to look so favorably on this young man after all. Sounds like his conviction's going to be affirmed, right?
But this case isn't about his conviction. It's about something else. Because Mr. Nunez pled guilty to voluntary manslaughter, and "[i]n June 2010, he was sentenced to serve 16 years in prison."
So what's it about? You may perhaps recall the details. If not, Justice Hull reminds you of just what transpired thereafter:
"On January 2, 2011, his last day in office as Governor of California, Arnold Schwarzenegger exercised his executive clemency power . . . by commuting (reducing) the prison sentence of Esteban Nunez from 16 years to seven years."
Then Justice Hull adds a paragraph break. After noting the "midnight" nature of the clemency, he adds:
"The commutation came as a complete surprise to the crime victims and the prosecuting district attorney."
Hmm. I wonder how Justice Hull feels about Gov. Schwarzenegger's decision?
One need not speculate. Justice Hull tells the reader exactly what he thinks: "We are compelled to conclude that, while Schwarzenegger’s conduct could be seen as deserving of censure and grossly unjust, it was not illegal. Marsy’s Law [which requires advance notification to victims parole and related proceedings], despite its obviously expansive protection of victims’ rights does not restrict the executive’s clemency powers under California Constitution, article V, section 8, subdivision (a) or the clemency statutes, and we must affirm the judgment."
"Deserving of censure" and "grossly unjust". Tell us what you really think, Justice Hull.
The Governator isn't the only one who's at the receiving end of the Court of Appeal's ire. Mr. Nunez doesn't get treated with kid gloves either. A brief sample of the Court of Appeal's opinion is more than enough to let you know what the justices think of him as well:
"Esteban Nunez’s self-serving letter to the court asserted he felt remorse, not for what he did, but for what “happened.” He blamed his codefendants for having “negative influences” on him. He claimed he “always intended to take responsibility for my actions” (despite fleeing the scene and destroying evidence) and was willing to turn himself in when the arrest warrant issued, but the district attorney was not interested. He said, “the justice system has its faults,” but “I still have hope the truth will be seen and heard. I guess I’m asking that you pay attention to the facts on this case, for the facts speak for themselves.”
Contrary to the content and tone of Nunez’s letter, the probation report states Nunez lied when first contacted by police, was “never cooperative,” and after his arrest and release sent a text message to a codefendant stating, 'Gangster rap made us do it lol.'"
Dude. After you've stabbed someone, and someone's been killed, it's probably not a good idea to send a mocking text message to your co-defendant. That tends to make you look, oh, I don't know: kinda bad.
Oh, and lest you think that the Court of Appeal is only displeased about the result, they've got some words about the process as well. Saying:
"On January 2, 2011, Schwarzenegger’s last day as Governor, he announced in an executive order signed on December 31, 2010, he had commuted Nunez’s sentence from 16 years to seven years. Back-room dealings were apparent. Esteban had filed a notice of appeal in the criminal case but signed a notice of abandonment and request for dismissal of appeal on December 6, 2010 -- before the grant of clemency. Nunez’s attorney signed the abandonment and dismissal request the day after the grant of clemency and filed it later, on January 20, 2011. Neither the victims nor the district attorney were notified that Schwarzenegger was considering commuting Nunez’s sentence."
In short, Mr. Nunez (and Gov. Schwarzenegger) essentially win the appeal, but get tarred in the process. Not that they perhaps care. But tarred they are. Mercilessly.
The Court of Appeal's opinion is unanimous. Both Justice Raye and Justice Murray, however, also write concurring opinions. The last paragraph of Justice Murray's concurrence begins: "As reprehensible as the Governor’s action in this instance might have been . . . ."
Lest there be any doubt from Justice Hull's opinion what the panel thinks.
People v. DeHoyos (Cal. Ct. App. - July 1, 2015)
This morning's opinion reminds us that methamphetamine users are not necessarily the brightest people in the universe. Even if they live in San Diego. Witness:
"San Diego Police Officers Andres Ruiz and Tyler Cockrell approached DeGraff while DeGraff was outside in front of his home cleaning his car. At the time, DeGraff's home was known to be a location where narcotics sales occurred. DeGraff agreed to speak with Ruiz. Ruiz asked him if he had ever been arrested and he stated he had. Ruiz asked him whether he was on probation or parole and he stated he was on probation. Ruiz asked whether he could search him and he responded, "Yes. I'm on probation."
Officer Ruiz searched DeGraff and found a folded paper containing 1.72 grams of methamphetamine in his back right pocket. Ruiz started handcuffing him and he asked why he was being arrested. When Ruiz told him he was being arrested for the methamphetamine in his pocket, he hung his head and remarked, "Oh, f--k. I didn't know that was there. I forgot. It's not mine." . . .
As Officer Ruiz was arresting DeGraff, DeGraff yelled to his girlfriend DeHoyos. DeHoyos came outside and Officer Cockrell contacted her. He asked her whether she had anything illegal on her and whether he could search her. She replied, "Yeah. I don't have anything on me." He searched her and found a baggie containing .50 grams of methamphetamine in her right front pocket. He then arrested her and placed her in the patrol car. . . .
After Officer Cockrell arrested DeHoyos, he asked DeGraff for permission to search his house. DeGraff verbally consented to the search. He also signed a written consent form after he had an opportunity to read the form and Cockrell read it to him. . . . Officer Ruiz searched DeGraff's home. He found a baggie containing 19.2 grams of methamphetamine in a bedroom being used as an office."
So let's summarize. Mr. DeGraff (1) consented to a search, and (2) forgot he was holding. Neither decision was bright. Then his girlfriend, Ms. DeHoyos, (1) comes out of her home while the police are there, (2) in possession of methamphetamine, and (3) consents to a search. Not too bright either.
Then Mr. DeGraff consents to a search of his home. In which there's even more methamphetamine.
Oh, one last thing. Mr. DeGraff tells the police officer he's on probation, and hence is authorized to search him. But he's actually not.
How you can forget whether you're on probation or not is beyond me.
Unless you're using way, way too much methamphetamine.
"San Diego Police Officers Andres Ruiz and Tyler Cockrell approached DeGraff while DeGraff was outside in front of his home cleaning his car. At the time, DeGraff's home was known to be a location where narcotics sales occurred. DeGraff agreed to speak with Ruiz. Ruiz asked him if he had ever been arrested and he stated he had. Ruiz asked him whether he was on probation or parole and he stated he was on probation. Ruiz asked whether he could search him and he responded, "Yes. I'm on probation."
Officer Ruiz searched DeGraff and found a folded paper containing 1.72 grams of methamphetamine in his back right pocket. Ruiz started handcuffing him and he asked why he was being arrested. When Ruiz told him he was being arrested for the methamphetamine in his pocket, he hung his head and remarked, "Oh, f--k. I didn't know that was there. I forgot. It's not mine." . . .
As Officer Ruiz was arresting DeGraff, DeGraff yelled to his girlfriend DeHoyos. DeHoyos came outside and Officer Cockrell contacted her. He asked her whether she had anything illegal on her and whether he could search her. She replied, "Yeah. I don't have anything on me." He searched her and found a baggie containing .50 grams of methamphetamine in her right front pocket. He then arrested her and placed her in the patrol car. . . .
After Officer Cockrell arrested DeHoyos, he asked DeGraff for permission to search his house. DeGraff verbally consented to the search. He also signed a written consent form after he had an opportunity to read the form and Cockrell read it to him. . . . Officer Ruiz searched DeGraff's home. He found a baggie containing 19.2 grams of methamphetamine in a bedroom being used as an office."
So let's summarize. Mr. DeGraff (1) consented to a search, and (2) forgot he was holding. Neither decision was bright. Then his girlfriend, Ms. DeHoyos, (1) comes out of her home while the police are there, (2) in possession of methamphetamine, and (3) consents to a search. Not too bright either.
Then Mr. DeGraff consents to a search of his home. In which there's even more methamphetamine.
Oh, one last thing. Mr. DeGraff tells the police officer he's on probation, and hence is authorized to search him. But he's actually not.
How you can forget whether you're on probation or not is beyond me.
Unless you're using way, way too much methamphetamine.
Tuesday, June 30, 2015
People v. Awad (Cal. Ct. App. - June 29, 2015)
This is an awesome opinion. It shows a manifest concern for justice. Three cheers for the Court of Appeal.
I'll let the 4/3 explain the thing in its own words:
"Appellant has appealed his felony conviction for multiple counts of forgery and grand theft and is currently serving a sentence for his conviction. Following his sentencing, in November 2014, the California voters enacted Proposition 47, entitled “the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act.” (See Note, Deering’s Ann. Pen. Code, foll. § 1170.18 (2015 supp.) p. 79.)
Proposition 47 reclassifies as misdemeanors certain non-serious, nonviolent crimes that previously were felonies, and authorizes trial courts to consider resentencing anyone who is currently serving a sentence for any of the listed offenses.
Appellant tried to take advantage of Proposition 47’s postconviction procedure by petitioning the trial court to reduce the felony sentence for one of his forgery counts to a misdemeanor. The trial court declined to do so, on the ground it lacked jurisdiction to recall the sentence while appellant’s case was pending on appeal.
Thus, appellant and many other similarly situated defendants face a Hobson’s choice. On the one hand, they can wait to seek Proposition 47 relief until they complete their appeals from the underlying judgment of conviction. But by then, it may be too late to gain any benefit from a sentencing reduction because they already will have served the time in question. On the other hand, they can give up any pending appeal in order to obtain speedy Proposition 47 relief from the trial court.
There is a way out of this jurisdictional conundrum: a discretionary remand by the Court of Appeal to the trial court for the sole and express purpose of determining, within a specified time frame, a Proposition 47 petition to recall a sentence. We have authority to do so pursuant to Penal Code section 12601 to effectuate the resentencing provisions in Proposition 47 in a timely manner.
We grant appellant’s motion for a limited remand, and stay the pending appeal for a short period of time to allow the trial court to conduct a Proposition 47 postconviction hearing."
The remaining nine pages of the opinion explain why the Court of Appeal is permitted to do what it has equitably decided to do. And it's right.
These are often short sentences. They may well be over by the time the case gets fully briefed and eventually heard in the Court of Appeal, and then booted back down for a Proposition 47 hearing. It makes sense to put the horse before the cart and do a limited remand on the Prop. 47 issue -- which only the trial court can do -- and thereafter adjudicate the full-fledged appeal. Well done.
This is an especially great move by the Court of Appeal because the 4/3 appears to have come up with the idea on its own. Appellant's counsel simply moved to expedite the appeal. It looks like the Court of Appeal was the one who came up with the "limited remand" concept. Great demonstration of initiative.
I also liked how the Court of Appeal ended its opinion: by remanding the case and ordering the completion of the Prop. 47 hearing within 45 days. With a report to the Court of Appeal five days after the hearing has been completed. In short: telling the trial court to get on the stick. Given that there are two departments in the trial court that apparently do nothing other than hear Prop. 47 motions, that seems a fair timetable. As well as efficient for everyone involved.
The only thing that made this whole process less than perfect -- albeit still very much commendable -- was giving the appellant multiple extensions of time to complete his brief (a total of over two months) and then granting respondent an extension of time for an additional month. Given the need for speed, perhaps counsel should be held to the fire as well. Not just the trial court.
Nonetheless: Great job, 4/3.
I'll let the 4/3 explain the thing in its own words:
"Appellant has appealed his felony conviction for multiple counts of forgery and grand theft and is currently serving a sentence for his conviction. Following his sentencing, in November 2014, the California voters enacted Proposition 47, entitled “the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act.” (See Note, Deering’s Ann. Pen. Code, foll. § 1170.18 (2015 supp.) p. 79.)
Proposition 47 reclassifies as misdemeanors certain non-serious, nonviolent crimes that previously were felonies, and authorizes trial courts to consider resentencing anyone who is currently serving a sentence for any of the listed offenses.
Appellant tried to take advantage of Proposition 47’s postconviction procedure by petitioning the trial court to reduce the felony sentence for one of his forgery counts to a misdemeanor. The trial court declined to do so, on the ground it lacked jurisdiction to recall the sentence while appellant’s case was pending on appeal.
Thus, appellant and many other similarly situated defendants face a Hobson’s choice. On the one hand, they can wait to seek Proposition 47 relief until they complete their appeals from the underlying judgment of conviction. But by then, it may be too late to gain any benefit from a sentencing reduction because they already will have served the time in question. On the other hand, they can give up any pending appeal in order to obtain speedy Proposition 47 relief from the trial court.
There is a way out of this jurisdictional conundrum: a discretionary remand by the Court of Appeal to the trial court for the sole and express purpose of determining, within a specified time frame, a Proposition 47 petition to recall a sentence. We have authority to do so pursuant to Penal Code section 12601 to effectuate the resentencing provisions in Proposition 47 in a timely manner.
We grant appellant’s motion for a limited remand, and stay the pending appeal for a short period of time to allow the trial court to conduct a Proposition 47 postconviction hearing."
The remaining nine pages of the opinion explain why the Court of Appeal is permitted to do what it has equitably decided to do. And it's right.
These are often short sentences. They may well be over by the time the case gets fully briefed and eventually heard in the Court of Appeal, and then booted back down for a Proposition 47 hearing. It makes sense to put the horse before the cart and do a limited remand on the Prop. 47 issue -- which only the trial court can do -- and thereafter adjudicate the full-fledged appeal. Well done.
This is an especially great move by the Court of Appeal because the 4/3 appears to have come up with the idea on its own. Appellant's counsel simply moved to expedite the appeal. It looks like the Court of Appeal was the one who came up with the "limited remand" concept. Great demonstration of initiative.
I also liked how the Court of Appeal ended its opinion: by remanding the case and ordering the completion of the Prop. 47 hearing within 45 days. With a report to the Court of Appeal five days after the hearing has been completed. In short: telling the trial court to get on the stick. Given that there are two departments in the trial court that apparently do nothing other than hear Prop. 47 motions, that seems a fair timetable. As well as efficient for everyone involved.
The only thing that made this whole process less than perfect -- albeit still very much commendable -- was giving the appellant multiple extensions of time to complete his brief (a total of over two months) and then granting respondent an extension of time for an additional month. Given the need for speed, perhaps counsel should be held to the fire as well. Not just the trial court.
Nonetheless: Great job, 4/3.
Ironridge Global v. ScripsAmerica (Cal. Ct. App. - June 30, 2015)
The rule's fairly simple: Follow the trial court's injunction, or get it stayed. If you do otherwise, you may well find your appeal dismissed.
As the Court of Appeal does here.
I'll add that today's opinion is also not a ringing endorsement of the appellant, ScripsAmerica, Inc. If it conducts its business like it litigates, you probably want to steer clear of the place.
Maybe that's why its stock is trading for six cents a share.
As the Court of Appeal does here.
I'll add that today's opinion is also not a ringing endorsement of the appellant, ScripsAmerica, Inc. If it conducts its business like it litigates, you probably want to steer clear of the place.
Maybe that's why its stock is trading for six cents a share.
Monday, June 29, 2015
Ninth Circuit Mandamus Actions (9th Cir. - June 29, 2015)
Today is apparently "Judge Jones" day in the Ninth Circuit.
Judge Jones, from the District of Nevada, is the subject of not one, but two (unrelated) published mandamus opinions today. The first stems from his routine practice of denying pro hac vice status to U.S. government attorneys. The United States finally got fed up with the practice and filed petitions for writs of mandamus. In that one, the Ninth Circuit declined to formally issue the writ, since Judge Jones had technically reversed the practice in the particular case in which the writ was filed, but still issued a published opinion that essentially made clear that Judge Jones should cut it out.
In the second opinion, the Ninth Circuit in fact issues a writ, in a case in which Judge Jones had involved himself in a criminal plea negotiation, and also assigned the case to a different judge on remand.
So not an especially good day for Judge Jones.
The criminal mandamus case was unanimous. The pro hac case, by contrast, was authored by Judge Milan Smith, but Judge Wallace concurred. Judge Wallace's main beef was that the court shouldn't have issued an advisory opinion (and he's got a point there), and that the problem was best resolved by the Judicial Council of the Circuit rather than on a writ. My sense is that Judge Smith didn't think that such a remedy was effective, particularly given how long Judge Jones has continued his practice, and felt like a more immediate response (e.g., a published opinion) would be preferable.
Two tiny additional things. First, I thought it was interesting that in the criminal mandamus case, the Ninth Circuit never once mentioned that the judge at issue was Judge Jones. Not once in the text, and (interestingly) not even in the caption. Usually -- like in the pro hac case -- you've got a line that says "On Petition for Writ of Mandamus to the United States District Court for the District of Nevada Robert Clive Jones, District Judge, Presiding". But in the criminal mandamus case today, the court leaves out that last part -- the part with Judge Jones' name. The only way you can tell who we're talking about is by reference to the district court case number, which ends with "RCJ"; i.e., Judge Jones.
The second interesting thing is that one of the members of the pro hac opinion is Judge Wallace. He was, indeed, the judge who concurred. That puts him in a slightly tough spot, because guess who was a law clerk for Judge Wallace after graduation? That's right: Judge Jones. Gotta be tough to preside over the alleged misconduct of a former clerk of yours.
Neat little opinions today. A little insight into some justice as practiced in one particular courtroom in Nevada.
Judge Jones, from the District of Nevada, is the subject of not one, but two (unrelated) published mandamus opinions today. The first stems from his routine practice of denying pro hac vice status to U.S. government attorneys. The United States finally got fed up with the practice and filed petitions for writs of mandamus. In that one, the Ninth Circuit declined to formally issue the writ, since Judge Jones had technically reversed the practice in the particular case in which the writ was filed, but still issued a published opinion that essentially made clear that Judge Jones should cut it out.
In the second opinion, the Ninth Circuit in fact issues a writ, in a case in which Judge Jones had involved himself in a criminal plea negotiation, and also assigned the case to a different judge on remand.
So not an especially good day for Judge Jones.
The criminal mandamus case was unanimous. The pro hac case, by contrast, was authored by Judge Milan Smith, but Judge Wallace concurred. Judge Wallace's main beef was that the court shouldn't have issued an advisory opinion (and he's got a point there), and that the problem was best resolved by the Judicial Council of the Circuit rather than on a writ. My sense is that Judge Smith didn't think that such a remedy was effective, particularly given how long Judge Jones has continued his practice, and felt like a more immediate response (e.g., a published opinion) would be preferable.
Two tiny additional things. First, I thought it was interesting that in the criminal mandamus case, the Ninth Circuit never once mentioned that the judge at issue was Judge Jones. Not once in the text, and (interestingly) not even in the caption. Usually -- like in the pro hac case -- you've got a line that says "On Petition for Writ of Mandamus to the United States District Court for the District of Nevada Robert Clive Jones, District Judge, Presiding". But in the criminal mandamus case today, the court leaves out that last part -- the part with Judge Jones' name. The only way you can tell who we're talking about is by reference to the district court case number, which ends with "RCJ"; i.e., Judge Jones.
The second interesting thing is that one of the members of the pro hac opinion is Judge Wallace. He was, indeed, the judge who concurred. That puts him in a slightly tough spot, because guess who was a law clerk for Judge Wallace after graduation? That's right: Judge Jones. Gotta be tough to preside over the alleged misconduct of a former clerk of yours.
Neat little opinions today. A little insight into some justice as practiced in one particular courtroom in Nevada.
Friday, June 26, 2015
U.S. v. Jefferson (9th Cir. June 26, 2015)
Headline: George Jefferson gets a decade in prison. He's no longer movin' on up. But he is going to the big house.
Okay, so it's not Sherman Helmsley's George Jefferson. But he is nonetheless a guy who's similarly feeling the sting of a particular social structure.
Mr. Jefferson drove a vehicle that contained some methampetamine into the U.S. He admitted that he knew his vehicle contained some drugs, but thought it was a small amount of marijuana.
Too bad. The Ninth Circuit follows binding precedent that says that it doesn't matter whether you knew the type of the drug or the quantity. You're still subject to the 10-year mandatory minimum. If you thought that Jimmy had put a single joint of marijuana in your glove box but it was actually a kilo of meth, you automatically get the full ten years. Mandatory. See ya in a decade, Joint Boy.
Judge Fletcher doesn't like that rule, and would overrule it. So writes a separate concurrence from Judge Wardlaw's opinion in which he expressly says so. But it's nonetheless the law. Sorry, Mr. Jefferson.
Two other tangential points. First, many of us are fairly well-aware of the crack/powder sentencing disparity with respect to cocaine, as well as what had been done to try to alleviate that problem. But I was surprised to discover today (as a result of Judge Wardlaw's opinion) just how methampetamine is treated.
You can import up to 50 kilos of marijuana, and there's (1) no mandatory minimum at all, and (2) a statutory maximum of 5 years. So marijuana is (not surprisingly) not huge deal. Cocaine is, to be expected, treated differently. Importing 500 grams of cocaine -- a little over a pound -- gets you a mandatory minimum of 5 years. Not surprising.
So where does methamphetamine fall along this line? About twenty times worse, by my count. Since 50 grams of meth (as opposed to 500 grams for cocaine) gets you a mandatory minimum of ten years (as contrasted with 5 for cocaine). So a tenth as much gets you double the time.
To an unsophisticated person like myself, this seems strange, if not crazy. Both cocaine and meth are "bad", but I would have thought that people thought cocaine was (maybe just a little) "worse". Or was at least worse on the "importation" front; we want to stop importing cocaine that would essentially cut off supply, since there's little to no home-grown cocaine, whereas there's plenty of domestic meth, so we'd presumably not feel as much of a need for a hammer on the importation front for the latter.
So I was surprised to see essentially a 20:1 ratio.
Now, I'll forthrightly admit that I'm a novice on this front, having never used either of the relevant drugs. So it may perhaps be that it takes more cocaine to put you where you want to be than it does meth. My unsophisticated brain thought they were both basically powders and a line was a line and hence basically equal. Thank God for the internet, of course. Though there's definitely no standard resource here, the sketchy places I've looked tend to suggest that maybe typical doses of cocaine are indeed a bit higher than typical doses of methampetamine. Though not at all like 20:1, and it also very much depends on how you use (e.g., snorting vs. IV).
And, again, on this front, I'm totally talking out of my butt.
Still, 20:1. Treating cocaine more favorably than methampetamine. That's surprising to me.
Second point. I was born in 1966, so I distinctly remember the efforts in the 1970s to get people to use the metric system. Meters, liters; all that good stuff. It was a total failure. People just didn't at all want to have to convert, say, 55 miles to hour to whatever kilometers per hour that might be. So the effort failed notwithstanding the indisputable value it would have to move our measuring systems to those used by the rest of the world with which we trade.
In that light, isn't it somewhat surprising how the metric system has totally caught on in the much more informal area of drugs? You ask for a "kilo" of cocaine, not a "pound". Even unsophisticated users who barely made it through junior high school know what a "gram" of methampetamine entails. The standard measure of heavy drugs is the metric system.
Isn't that weird?
(Mind you, it also makes it very easy for even casual observers to figure out who the drug dealers are; say, in high school. When I was a kid, all I had to do to figure out if a guy was "in the know" was to ask him how many grams were in a pound. Any denim-jacket wearing dude who knew the answer to that question was a guy who either sold himself or who knew plenty of people who did.)
It's also a bit funny because my sense is that for marijuana, it's different. There, in general, we use the English system; an ounce, an "eighth" (of an ounce), a pound, etc.
(Mind you, in the modern "medical" marijuana industry, there's been a demonstrable shift towards grams, so even here, the metric system's making far more inroads than it ever did in modern culture. Two liter bottles aside. Plus, I admit that the English system still has some use on the "hard drugs" side. "Eightballs" of cocaine, for example; e.g., an eighth of an ounce. Still, I think the metric system dominates on the non-marijuana side of things.)
My only way of potentially reconciling the difference between the use of the metric system for "real" drugs and the English system for marijuana is that maybe it arose because the former is generally imported whereas there's a large home-grown market for the latter. So maybe we followed "kilos" when we discussed, say, cocaine and heroin because that's the measure that the producers of those products used, and we dutifully followed along. Even though in "normal" international trade we expected the use of our own system. Whereas in marijuana the presence of a nontrivial domestic production market let us indulge ourselves in the use of our own system.
That's not a perfect explanation, since meth has a big home-grown component too, and there's a fair amount of imported marijuana. But it's at least a shot. Otherwise I'm not at all sure why drug users have a much better knowledge of the metric system-- or at least weights and measures therein -- than, I'd estimate, 90 percent of "average" Americans.
Americans: We like our speedometers in English, but our drugs in metric.
Okay, so it's not Sherman Helmsley's George Jefferson. But he is nonetheless a guy who's similarly feeling the sting of a particular social structure.
Mr. Jefferson drove a vehicle that contained some methampetamine into the U.S. He admitted that he knew his vehicle contained some drugs, but thought it was a small amount of marijuana.
Too bad. The Ninth Circuit follows binding precedent that says that it doesn't matter whether you knew the type of the drug or the quantity. You're still subject to the 10-year mandatory minimum. If you thought that Jimmy had put a single joint of marijuana in your glove box but it was actually a kilo of meth, you automatically get the full ten years. Mandatory. See ya in a decade, Joint Boy.
Judge Fletcher doesn't like that rule, and would overrule it. So writes a separate concurrence from Judge Wardlaw's opinion in which he expressly says so. But it's nonetheless the law. Sorry, Mr. Jefferson.
Two other tangential points. First, many of us are fairly well-aware of the crack/powder sentencing disparity with respect to cocaine, as well as what had been done to try to alleviate that problem. But I was surprised to discover today (as a result of Judge Wardlaw's opinion) just how methampetamine is treated.
You can import up to 50 kilos of marijuana, and there's (1) no mandatory minimum at all, and (2) a statutory maximum of 5 years. So marijuana is (not surprisingly) not huge deal. Cocaine is, to be expected, treated differently. Importing 500 grams of cocaine -- a little over a pound -- gets you a mandatory minimum of 5 years. Not surprising.
So where does methamphetamine fall along this line? About twenty times worse, by my count. Since 50 grams of meth (as opposed to 500 grams for cocaine) gets you a mandatory minimum of ten years (as contrasted with 5 for cocaine). So a tenth as much gets you double the time.
To an unsophisticated person like myself, this seems strange, if not crazy. Both cocaine and meth are "bad", but I would have thought that people thought cocaine was (maybe just a little) "worse". Or was at least worse on the "importation" front; we want to stop importing cocaine that would essentially cut off supply, since there's little to no home-grown cocaine, whereas there's plenty of domestic meth, so we'd presumably not feel as much of a need for a hammer on the importation front for the latter.
So I was surprised to see essentially a 20:1 ratio.
Now, I'll forthrightly admit that I'm a novice on this front, having never used either of the relevant drugs. So it may perhaps be that it takes more cocaine to put you where you want to be than it does meth. My unsophisticated brain thought they were both basically powders and a line was a line and hence basically equal. Thank God for the internet, of course. Though there's definitely no standard resource here, the sketchy places I've looked tend to suggest that maybe typical doses of cocaine are indeed a bit higher than typical doses of methampetamine. Though not at all like 20:1, and it also very much depends on how you use (e.g., snorting vs. IV).
And, again, on this front, I'm totally talking out of my butt.
Still, 20:1. Treating cocaine more favorably than methampetamine. That's surprising to me.
Second point. I was born in 1966, so I distinctly remember the efforts in the 1970s to get people to use the metric system. Meters, liters; all that good stuff. It was a total failure. People just didn't at all want to have to convert, say, 55 miles to hour to whatever kilometers per hour that might be. So the effort failed notwithstanding the indisputable value it would have to move our measuring systems to those used by the rest of the world with which we trade.
In that light, isn't it somewhat surprising how the metric system has totally caught on in the much more informal area of drugs? You ask for a "kilo" of cocaine, not a "pound". Even unsophisticated users who barely made it through junior high school know what a "gram" of methampetamine entails. The standard measure of heavy drugs is the metric system.
Isn't that weird?
(Mind you, it also makes it very easy for even casual observers to figure out who the drug dealers are; say, in high school. When I was a kid, all I had to do to figure out if a guy was "in the know" was to ask him how many grams were in a pound. Any denim-jacket wearing dude who knew the answer to that question was a guy who either sold himself or who knew plenty of people who did.)
It's also a bit funny because my sense is that for marijuana, it's different. There, in general, we use the English system; an ounce, an "eighth" (of an ounce), a pound, etc.
(Mind you, in the modern "medical" marijuana industry, there's been a demonstrable shift towards grams, so even here, the metric system's making far more inroads than it ever did in modern culture. Two liter bottles aside. Plus, I admit that the English system still has some use on the "hard drugs" side. "Eightballs" of cocaine, for example; e.g., an eighth of an ounce. Still, I think the metric system dominates on the non-marijuana side of things.)
My only way of potentially reconciling the difference between the use of the metric system for "real" drugs and the English system for marijuana is that maybe it arose because the former is generally imported whereas there's a large home-grown market for the latter. So maybe we followed "kilos" when we discussed, say, cocaine and heroin because that's the measure that the producers of those products used, and we dutifully followed along. Even though in "normal" international trade we expected the use of our own system. Whereas in marijuana the presence of a nontrivial domestic production market let us indulge ourselves in the use of our own system.
That's not a perfect explanation, since meth has a big home-grown component too, and there's a fair amount of imported marijuana. But it's at least a shot. Otherwise I'm not at all sure why drug users have a much better knowledge of the metric system-- or at least weights and measures therein -- than, I'd estimate, 90 percent of "average" Americans.
Americans: We like our speedometers in English, but our drugs in metric.
Thursday, June 25, 2015
People v. McDonald (Cal. Ct. App. - June 25, 2015)
There's such a fine line between a tiny little bit in prison and a ton of time in prison:
"On August 19, 2012, Christopher Patterson snatched a gold chain from around the neck of 71-year-old Guadalupe Ramos. In the process, he either knocked or threw her to the pavement of a grocery store parking lot. . . . Guadalupe developed an irregular heartbeat. She was pronounced dead about an hour after the robbery."
If things had gone as planned, and the snatch-and-grab would have worked out as it was intended (e.g., the chain broke easily), Mr. Patterson would have been guilty of a relatively minor offense. As it actually transpired, however, he's facing first degree murder charges.
So too is the defendant in today's opinion: a guy named Maxamillion McDonald, who sat in a car waiting for Mr. Patterson to return. He gets convicted on first degree murder as well. As well as sentenced to life without the possibility of parole. Plus 12 years.
The Court of Appeal reverses various convictions on instructional (and other) grounds, so Mr. McDonald gets some relief. At least for now. We'll see what happens on remand.
But the Court of Appeal doesn't do so due to the totally happenstance nature of the offense. We still impart incredible significance in sentencing to chance: A and B may commit the exact same crime, in exact same settings, but if A's victim falls one way, and B's victim falls another, the punishment we give to identical acts is often radically disparate.
P.S. - As to how Ms. Ramos died: "Visual examination of the body at autopsy showed abrasions and contusions to the right side of Guadalupe’s body, including her neck. She had a history of hypertension, and the autopsy revealed some kidney disease, fibrosis in the lungs, and a fatty liver. The cause of death was determined to be cardiac dysrhythmia (irregular heartbeat), associated with blunt force trauma on the trunk and extremities. Basically, the marked excitation accompanied by physical exertion and emotional distress surrounding the event accelerated her heart rate and led to internal imbalance. There was a surge of adrenaline, followed by deceleration during the waning effect of the adrenalin, causing the heart to beat irregularly and leading to a heart attack. In essence, Guadalupe literally was scared to death."
"On August 19, 2012, Christopher Patterson snatched a gold chain from around the neck of 71-year-old Guadalupe Ramos. In the process, he either knocked or threw her to the pavement of a grocery store parking lot. . . . Guadalupe developed an irregular heartbeat. She was pronounced dead about an hour after the robbery."
If things had gone as planned, and the snatch-and-grab would have worked out as it was intended (e.g., the chain broke easily), Mr. Patterson would have been guilty of a relatively minor offense. As it actually transpired, however, he's facing first degree murder charges.
So too is the defendant in today's opinion: a guy named Maxamillion McDonald, who sat in a car waiting for Mr. Patterson to return. He gets convicted on first degree murder as well. As well as sentenced to life without the possibility of parole. Plus 12 years.
The Court of Appeal reverses various convictions on instructional (and other) grounds, so Mr. McDonald gets some relief. At least for now. We'll see what happens on remand.
But the Court of Appeal doesn't do so due to the totally happenstance nature of the offense. We still impart incredible significance in sentencing to chance: A and B may commit the exact same crime, in exact same settings, but if A's victim falls one way, and B's victim falls another, the punishment we give to identical acts is often radically disparate.
P.S. - As to how Ms. Ramos died: "Visual examination of the body at autopsy showed abrasions and contusions to the right side of Guadalupe’s body, including her neck. She had a history of hypertension, and the autopsy revealed some kidney disease, fibrosis in the lungs, and a fatty liver. The cause of death was determined to be cardiac dysrhythmia (irregular heartbeat), associated with blunt force trauma on the trunk and extremities. Basically, the marked excitation accompanied by physical exertion and emotional distress surrounding the event accelerated her heart rate and led to internal imbalance. There was a surge of adrenaline, followed by deceleration during the waning effect of the adrenalin, causing the heart to beat irregularly and leading to a heart attack. In essence, Guadalupe literally was scared to death."
Wednesday, June 24, 2015
Wong v. Stoler (Cal. Ct. App. - June 23, 2015)
Unlike the Court of Appeal, I sort of liked what the trial court (Judge Buchwald from San Mateo) did here. Though I understand why the Court of Appeal had to reverse. Still, on remand, I might continue to lean in the direction of the trial court's sentiment rather than the Court of Appeal's.
It's a "fraud" case. Though only marginally. Ira and Toby Stoler have a beautiful home in San Mateo. They sell it to Wayson and Susanna Wong for $2.35 million. (Sucks to be poor, eh?)
The sellers fill out the usual paperwork, including a transfer disclosure statement that says that there's no HOA and that the home was connected to a public sewer system. But these statements were only "sort of" correct. Whether the Stolers knew it or not, the developer of the property (including the property of a dozen of the Stolers' neighbors) actually built a private sewage line to connect all the properties together and then ran it down a hill to connect it to the public line. So the home was technically itself connected only to the private line, and while there was no formal HOA, the 1,000-foot private line was legally owned in common by the 13 homeowners that connected to it; e.g., they'd be responsible for any repairs and/or breaks.
So that's a negligent misrepresentation by the Stolers. Which is admittedly wrong. Regardless of the fact that the CC&Rs (reviewed by the Wongs) sort of mention this private sewer line. The Stolers should not have said what they did.
The Wongs originally try to deal with the problem in a neighborly fashion, and try to simply get the City of San Mateo to take over the line. But no dice. So then they hire lawyers. Who sue the Stolers as well as the real estate agent.
What remedy do the Wongs want?
You might initially think damages. The difference between the value of the home they thought they bought (with a public sewage line) versus the value of the home they actually did buy (with a shared interest in 1000 feet of a private line).
That probably wouldn't be a massive amount of money. It'd matter a bit to most buyers, perhaps. It's some exposure. But in the grand scheme of things, not much. Bet it didn't matter virtually at all, for example, to the 13 buyers who built it from the developer.
So if that's the measure of damages -- and surely full compensation is a just result -- then we can resolve this lawsuit fairly easily. Indeed, we can easily resolve it, since the Wongs already got a $200,000 settlement from the real estate agent. I'm confident that's more than sufficient to cover an actual damages remedy.
But did I mention that the sale of this $2.35 million home transpired in 2008? That's right. Immediately prior to the crash. And consequent plastering of real estate values.
Now can you figure out what remedy the buyers want?
That's right. Rescission. They want to give the house back to the Stolers and have their $2.35 million refunded. Never mind the fact that the Wongs have, in the meantime, remodeled the property and (in the words of the Court of Appeal "much of the home was down to the studs as a result of the demolition work." The Wongs want the full purchase price back, regardless of the downturn in the market, and are willing to give what's left of the studs back to the Stolers.
All because of some erroneous wording about a 1000-foot private sewage line.
The trial court doesn't like that. It things that rescission is an equitable remedy. Which it is. The trial judge doesn't think the Wongs' demand for relief is equitable. Which, IMHO, it's not.
So he comes up with a creative solution. The Wongs get to keep the house. But the Stolers will be responsible for any repairs, maintenance, or replacement of the private sewage line. Either for 10 years or until the Wongs sell the house, whichever comes first. With a cap of $360,000 in liability, offset against the $200,000 the Wongs already received in the prior settlement. That way the Wongs will essentially get what they thought they were buying: a particular house, but without the burden of having to potentially repair a private sewage line.
Nice. Creative. Fair. I applaud Judge Buchwald.
Admittedly, I would still reverse. The Court of Appeal is right that the trial court's remedy doesn't fully put the Wongs in the position they thought they'd be in. Or one thing, what if repairs cost over $360,000? For another, what if the repairs were required in the 11th year rather than the 10th? Finally, what about the fact that the Wongs are now going to have to disclose this private sewer line to the next buyer, with no indemnity by the Stolers -- hence perhaps reducing the selling price of the home?
Those are all problems. They aren't solved by the trial court's remedy. So I agree we need to try something else.
Mind you, I think there is a solution in equity. My thought is that we simply make the Stolers responsible for the property's share of the private line. Period.
We have a name for that sort of thing. Insurance.
In my mind, we simply have the court declare that the Stolers are responsible, and the Stolers respond by buying an insurance policy to cover any required repairs. Maybe the premium's $1,000/year. Maybe it's $5,000/year. Whatever. The Stolers just purchase the policy and pay for it. That way the Wongs get the property they were promised and we're good to go. Fair and equitable.
As a bonus, this remedy also gives the Stolers a possible out. Several, even. If they don't want to buy insurance, they can make a sum-certain deal with the Wongs to get out of it. A lump sum payment of $50,000 (or $150,000, or whatever). Then when the Wongs sell the home to the next person they disclose the private line and everything's hunky dory forever. Alternately, the Stolers can buy the insurance (or take on the liability themselves) and, sometime down the line, buy the house from the Wongs (or a subsequent purchaser) and then immediately flip it with full disclosure. My bet is that'd cost the Stolers only a minimal amount of money, since my guess is that buyers won't actually care much about the private line.
Regardless, there's an equitable solution available. Something that makes the Wongs whole -- maybe even more than whole given the prior $200,000 settlement -- and yet doesn't unjustly hose the Stolers.
So I think a solution like that, potentially on remand, would be a very fair way of resolving the case.
But that's not what the Court of Appeal does.
The Court of Appeal instead just takes the case at total face value. As if the origins here were not based in equity, nor contain equitable limitations. It says that victims of fraud are entitled to rescind, and this counts as fraud, so the Wongs get to rescind. End of story. Sure, there are some complexities about the value of the Wongs' improvements, and the cut shrubbery, etc. But that's all detail. The Wongs get to rescind.
Which is what they want. Precisely because it gives them a windfall. They buy the house at the top of the market, and want to give it back once property values plummet. The latter event having nothing to do with the negligent error made by the Stolers.
I like my remedy better.
In the end, hopefully, as things turned out, maybe the inequitable nature of the Court of Appeal's remedy will have dissipated by now. Because guess what? The real estate market has turned.
The Wongs say that they want their $2.35 million back. Okay. At least according to Zillow, the value of the property is now over $3.4 million. So if they want $2.35 million for it, I bet the Stolers may well take that deal. Heck, the Wongs can even keep the extra $200,000 settlement. Even though rescission means that they're supposed to turn over pretty much everything they got; e.g., including the $200K.
Lest there be any doubt that it's the general real estate market -- not the actual consequences of the Stolers' misrepresentation -- that's driving the action here, my money's on the Wongs no longer seeking to turn over the property in return for their $2.35 million.
The Court of Appeal's opinion, unlike the trial court's, gives the Wongs a one-way option on the overall real estate market. That's not attractive to me. And may work a serious injustice.
At least in the present case, I hope it doesn't matter. Hopefully the option is valueless.
Since I'm not sure it should have been given in the first place.
It's a "fraud" case. Though only marginally. Ira and Toby Stoler have a beautiful home in San Mateo. They sell it to Wayson and Susanna Wong for $2.35 million. (Sucks to be poor, eh?)
The sellers fill out the usual paperwork, including a transfer disclosure statement that says that there's no HOA and that the home was connected to a public sewer system. But these statements were only "sort of" correct. Whether the Stolers knew it or not, the developer of the property (including the property of a dozen of the Stolers' neighbors) actually built a private sewage line to connect all the properties together and then ran it down a hill to connect it to the public line. So the home was technically itself connected only to the private line, and while there was no formal HOA, the 1,000-foot private line was legally owned in common by the 13 homeowners that connected to it; e.g., they'd be responsible for any repairs and/or breaks.
So that's a negligent misrepresentation by the Stolers. Which is admittedly wrong. Regardless of the fact that the CC&Rs (reviewed by the Wongs) sort of mention this private sewer line. The Stolers should not have said what they did.
The Wongs originally try to deal with the problem in a neighborly fashion, and try to simply get the City of San Mateo to take over the line. But no dice. So then they hire lawyers. Who sue the Stolers as well as the real estate agent.
What remedy do the Wongs want?
You might initially think damages. The difference between the value of the home they thought they bought (with a public sewage line) versus the value of the home they actually did buy (with a shared interest in 1000 feet of a private line).
That probably wouldn't be a massive amount of money. It'd matter a bit to most buyers, perhaps. It's some exposure. But in the grand scheme of things, not much. Bet it didn't matter virtually at all, for example, to the 13 buyers who built it from the developer.
So if that's the measure of damages -- and surely full compensation is a just result -- then we can resolve this lawsuit fairly easily. Indeed, we can easily resolve it, since the Wongs already got a $200,000 settlement from the real estate agent. I'm confident that's more than sufficient to cover an actual damages remedy.
But did I mention that the sale of this $2.35 million home transpired in 2008? That's right. Immediately prior to the crash. And consequent plastering of real estate values.
Now can you figure out what remedy the buyers want?
That's right. Rescission. They want to give the house back to the Stolers and have their $2.35 million refunded. Never mind the fact that the Wongs have, in the meantime, remodeled the property and (in the words of the Court of Appeal "much of the home was down to the studs as a result of the demolition work." The Wongs want the full purchase price back, regardless of the downturn in the market, and are willing to give what's left of the studs back to the Stolers.
All because of some erroneous wording about a 1000-foot private sewage line.
The trial court doesn't like that. It things that rescission is an equitable remedy. Which it is. The trial judge doesn't think the Wongs' demand for relief is equitable. Which, IMHO, it's not.
So he comes up with a creative solution. The Wongs get to keep the house. But the Stolers will be responsible for any repairs, maintenance, or replacement of the private sewage line. Either for 10 years or until the Wongs sell the house, whichever comes first. With a cap of $360,000 in liability, offset against the $200,000 the Wongs already received in the prior settlement. That way the Wongs will essentially get what they thought they were buying: a particular house, but without the burden of having to potentially repair a private sewage line.
Nice. Creative. Fair. I applaud Judge Buchwald.
Admittedly, I would still reverse. The Court of Appeal is right that the trial court's remedy doesn't fully put the Wongs in the position they thought they'd be in. Or one thing, what if repairs cost over $360,000? For another, what if the repairs were required in the 11th year rather than the 10th? Finally, what about the fact that the Wongs are now going to have to disclose this private sewer line to the next buyer, with no indemnity by the Stolers -- hence perhaps reducing the selling price of the home?
Those are all problems. They aren't solved by the trial court's remedy. So I agree we need to try something else.
Mind you, I think there is a solution in equity. My thought is that we simply make the Stolers responsible for the property's share of the private line. Period.
We have a name for that sort of thing. Insurance.
In my mind, we simply have the court declare that the Stolers are responsible, and the Stolers respond by buying an insurance policy to cover any required repairs. Maybe the premium's $1,000/year. Maybe it's $5,000/year. Whatever. The Stolers just purchase the policy and pay for it. That way the Wongs get the property they were promised and we're good to go. Fair and equitable.
As a bonus, this remedy also gives the Stolers a possible out. Several, even. If they don't want to buy insurance, they can make a sum-certain deal with the Wongs to get out of it. A lump sum payment of $50,000 (or $150,000, or whatever). Then when the Wongs sell the home to the next person they disclose the private line and everything's hunky dory forever. Alternately, the Stolers can buy the insurance (or take on the liability themselves) and, sometime down the line, buy the house from the Wongs (or a subsequent purchaser) and then immediately flip it with full disclosure. My bet is that'd cost the Stolers only a minimal amount of money, since my guess is that buyers won't actually care much about the private line.
Regardless, there's an equitable solution available. Something that makes the Wongs whole -- maybe even more than whole given the prior $200,000 settlement -- and yet doesn't unjustly hose the Stolers.
So I think a solution like that, potentially on remand, would be a very fair way of resolving the case.
But that's not what the Court of Appeal does.
The Court of Appeal instead just takes the case at total face value. As if the origins here were not based in equity, nor contain equitable limitations. It says that victims of fraud are entitled to rescind, and this counts as fraud, so the Wongs get to rescind. End of story. Sure, there are some complexities about the value of the Wongs' improvements, and the cut shrubbery, etc. But that's all detail. The Wongs get to rescind.
Which is what they want. Precisely because it gives them a windfall. They buy the house at the top of the market, and want to give it back once property values plummet. The latter event having nothing to do with the negligent error made by the Stolers.
I like my remedy better.
In the end, hopefully, as things turned out, maybe the inequitable nature of the Court of Appeal's remedy will have dissipated by now. Because guess what? The real estate market has turned.
The Wongs say that they want their $2.35 million back. Okay. At least according to Zillow, the value of the property is now over $3.4 million. So if they want $2.35 million for it, I bet the Stolers may well take that deal. Heck, the Wongs can even keep the extra $200,000 settlement. Even though rescission means that they're supposed to turn over pretty much everything they got; e.g., including the $200K.
Lest there be any doubt that it's the general real estate market -- not the actual consequences of the Stolers' misrepresentation -- that's driving the action here, my money's on the Wongs no longer seeking to turn over the property in return for their $2.35 million.
The Court of Appeal's opinion, unlike the trial court's, gives the Wongs a one-way option on the overall real estate market. That's not attractive to me. And may work a serious injustice.
At least in the present case, I hope it doesn't matter. Hopefully the option is valueless.
Since I'm not sure it should have been given in the first place.
U.S. v. Rodriguez (9th Cir. - June 24, 2015)
Judge Silverman captures my sentiments precisely in the opening paragraphs of this morning's opinion:
"There ought to be a law against shining a laser pointer at an aircraft. In fact, there is, and it’s punishable by up to five years in prison, as appellant Sergio Rodriguez discovered for himself. Rodriguez, his girlfriend, and their kids were fooling around with a laser pointer one summer evening in the courtyard of their apartment complex – trying to see just how far it could go – and they shined it at overflying helicopters. Rodriguez was convicted of Aiming a Laser Pointer at an Aircraft, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 39A, and was sentenced to the maximum sentence: five years in prison. Rodriguez does not challenge that conviction.
He also was convicted of another crime stemming from the same conduct – Attempting to Interfere with the Safe Operation of an Aircraft, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 32(a)(5) and (8). That crime requires proof of a willful attempt to interfere with the operator of an aircraft, with either the intent to endanger others or reckless disregard for human life. Rodriguez was charged with and found guilty of the reckless variety, and for that offense, was sentenced to fourteen years in prison.
The evidence clearly shows that Rodriguez was rightfully convicted of aiming the laser pointer at a helicopter (§ 39A). However, there is insufficient evidence that he willfully attempted to interfere with the safe flight of the helicopter (§ 32(a)(5)). Rather, the evidence showed that he was attempting to see how far his laser would go at night – a stupid thing to do, yes, but there is no evidence that he was trying to interfere with the pilot. Section 39A is designed for knuckleheads like him. On the other hand, 18 U.S.C. § 32(a)(5) is designed for both the Osama bin Ladens of the world – people trying to bring down a plane, intending to cause harm – and those who are aware that their actions are dangerous and could harm others, but just don’t care. The failure to recognize this distinction is to fail to appreciate that Congress saw fit to create two different crimes, one more serious than the other, for two different types of offenders.
About a year after Rodriguez’s conviction became final in district court, we decided United States v. Gardenhire, 784 F.3d 1277 (9th Cir. 2015). On very similar facts – a case in which another knucklehead aimed a laser pointer at a passing airplane just for the fun of it – we held, for the purposes of the applicable sentencing guidelines, that there was no evidence “that Gardenhire acted recklessly when he aimed his laser beam at the aircraft. The record is devoid of evidence, let alone clear and convincing evidence, that Gardenhire was aware of the risk created by his conduct.” Id. at 1280.
We face a similar situation here. There’s no problem with Rodriguez’s conviction for Aiming a Laser Pointer at an Aircraft, 18 U.S.C. § 39A. But his conviction under 18 U.S.C. § 32(a)(5), (a)(8), for Attempting to Interfere with the Safe Operation of an Aircraft, required both proof of a willful attempt to interfere with an aircraft, and proof of a reckless disregard for human life. That conviction is not supported by the evidence and must be reversed. Because the district court did not have the benefit of Gardenhire and because it premised the sentence for the § 39A conviction, in part, on the fact that Rodriguez had also been convicted of violating § 32(a)(5), (a)(8), we also remand for resentencing on the § 39A conviction."
I think "knucklehead" is an exactly right appellation for offenders of this sort. Wouldn't have thought of it myself, but glad that Judge Silverman did. As well as repeatedly uses it.
For my part, I'll mention only that I think it's similarly knuckleheaded -- though admittedly not as much -- to sentence a guy to fourteen years in prison for being an idiot. Or, to be honest, even to sentence someone like Mr. Rodriguez (as Judge O'Neill did) to the maximum five years in prison for the § 39A offense. Or even to authorize (as Congress and the President did) such a sentence.
It's massive overkill. As well as ruins lives for no reason.
Knuckleheads like Mr. Rodriguez aren't going to be more prospectively deterred by a five-year sentence than they will be by a one-year sentence. They don't even know it's a crime. Or (most likely) dangerous. And if they did, they'd almost certainly either (1) not do it if they thought there was any chance of spending a full year of their life in prison as a result, or (2) do it anyway, regardless of the possible sentence, because they're simply morons.
Length of sentences sometimes matters. What you do during a kidnapping may depend on the severity of the resulting sentence. Drug offenses might be deterred by the length of a particular sentence. There are surely situations in which you successfully deter someone by threatening a higher sentence.
Laser pointer crimes aren't one of them.
We'd be much better off -- e.g, the world would be safer -- if we took the $100,000 or so that we'll directly spend on Mr. Rodriguez's five-year incarceration and spend it on advertisements telling the public that's it's dangerous (and a crime) to point lasers at aircraft. As a neat side benefit, that'd also salvage a significant portion of Mr. Rodriguez's life (i.e., five years of freedom), and benefit his family, friends, and everyone who will be required to support Mr. Rodriguez and his family both during his incarceration as well as thereafter.
People shouldn't shoot laser pointers at planes or (as here) helicopters. People shouldn't think that laser pointers purchased for $7 on amazon.com -- which is where the present one came from -- are merely toys and are completely harmless. Though I know full well that many do.
But imposing long sentences on such knuckleheads doesn't make any sense either.
And that's a mistake that emanates from people who should know better.
"There ought to be a law against shining a laser pointer at an aircraft. In fact, there is, and it’s punishable by up to five years in prison, as appellant Sergio Rodriguez discovered for himself. Rodriguez, his girlfriend, and their kids were fooling around with a laser pointer one summer evening in the courtyard of their apartment complex – trying to see just how far it could go – and they shined it at overflying helicopters. Rodriguez was convicted of Aiming a Laser Pointer at an Aircraft, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 39A, and was sentenced to the maximum sentence: five years in prison. Rodriguez does not challenge that conviction.
He also was convicted of another crime stemming from the same conduct – Attempting to Interfere with the Safe Operation of an Aircraft, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 32(a)(5) and (8). That crime requires proof of a willful attempt to interfere with the operator of an aircraft, with either the intent to endanger others or reckless disregard for human life. Rodriguez was charged with and found guilty of the reckless variety, and for that offense, was sentenced to fourteen years in prison.
The evidence clearly shows that Rodriguez was rightfully convicted of aiming the laser pointer at a helicopter (§ 39A). However, there is insufficient evidence that he willfully attempted to interfere with the safe flight of the helicopter (§ 32(a)(5)). Rather, the evidence showed that he was attempting to see how far his laser would go at night – a stupid thing to do, yes, but there is no evidence that he was trying to interfere with the pilot. Section 39A is designed for knuckleheads like him. On the other hand, 18 U.S.C. § 32(a)(5) is designed for both the Osama bin Ladens of the world – people trying to bring down a plane, intending to cause harm – and those who are aware that their actions are dangerous and could harm others, but just don’t care. The failure to recognize this distinction is to fail to appreciate that Congress saw fit to create two different crimes, one more serious than the other, for two different types of offenders.
About a year after Rodriguez’s conviction became final in district court, we decided United States v. Gardenhire, 784 F.3d 1277 (9th Cir. 2015). On very similar facts – a case in which another knucklehead aimed a laser pointer at a passing airplane just for the fun of it – we held, for the purposes of the applicable sentencing guidelines, that there was no evidence “that Gardenhire acted recklessly when he aimed his laser beam at the aircraft. The record is devoid of evidence, let alone clear and convincing evidence, that Gardenhire was aware of the risk created by his conduct.” Id. at 1280.
We face a similar situation here. There’s no problem with Rodriguez’s conviction for Aiming a Laser Pointer at an Aircraft, 18 U.S.C. § 39A. But his conviction under 18 U.S.C. § 32(a)(5), (a)(8), for Attempting to Interfere with the Safe Operation of an Aircraft, required both proof of a willful attempt to interfere with an aircraft, and proof of a reckless disregard for human life. That conviction is not supported by the evidence and must be reversed. Because the district court did not have the benefit of Gardenhire and because it premised the sentence for the § 39A conviction, in part, on the fact that Rodriguez had also been convicted of violating § 32(a)(5), (a)(8), we also remand for resentencing on the § 39A conviction."
I think "knucklehead" is an exactly right appellation for offenders of this sort. Wouldn't have thought of it myself, but glad that Judge Silverman did. As well as repeatedly uses it.
For my part, I'll mention only that I think it's similarly knuckleheaded -- though admittedly not as much -- to sentence a guy to fourteen years in prison for being an idiot. Or, to be honest, even to sentence someone like Mr. Rodriguez (as Judge O'Neill did) to the maximum five years in prison for the § 39A offense. Or even to authorize (as Congress and the President did) such a sentence.
It's massive overkill. As well as ruins lives for no reason.
Knuckleheads like Mr. Rodriguez aren't going to be more prospectively deterred by a five-year sentence than they will be by a one-year sentence. They don't even know it's a crime. Or (most likely) dangerous. And if they did, they'd almost certainly either (1) not do it if they thought there was any chance of spending a full year of their life in prison as a result, or (2) do it anyway, regardless of the possible sentence, because they're simply morons.
Length of sentences sometimes matters. What you do during a kidnapping may depend on the severity of the resulting sentence. Drug offenses might be deterred by the length of a particular sentence. There are surely situations in which you successfully deter someone by threatening a higher sentence.
Laser pointer crimes aren't one of them.
We'd be much better off -- e.g, the world would be safer -- if we took the $100,000 or so that we'll directly spend on Mr. Rodriguez's five-year incarceration and spend it on advertisements telling the public that's it's dangerous (and a crime) to point lasers at aircraft. As a neat side benefit, that'd also salvage a significant portion of Mr. Rodriguez's life (i.e., five years of freedom), and benefit his family, friends, and everyone who will be required to support Mr. Rodriguez and his family both during his incarceration as well as thereafter.
People shouldn't shoot laser pointers at planes or (as here) helicopters. People shouldn't think that laser pointers purchased for $7 on amazon.com -- which is where the present one came from -- are merely toys and are completely harmless. Though I know full well that many do.
But imposing long sentences on such knuckleheads doesn't make any sense either.
And that's a mistake that emanates from people who should know better.
Tuesday, June 23, 2015
People v. Sokau (Cal. Ct. App. - June 23, 2015)
Well, now. This is a really interesting dispute. I'm not completely sure what I think about it.
Everyone agrees on the factual underpinnings. Richard Sokau had a terrible interpreter at his trial. A really, really terrible one. The judge knew it; the prosecutor knew it; the defense counsel knew it; and I'm sure everyone in the courtroom knew it as well. I'm not sure how hard it is -- or should be -- for a certified interpreter to translate Palauan (the language of Palau) into English and vice-versa. But the interpreter here failed on nearly every metric.
On that everyone agrees.
But what to do about it?
On the one hand, the defendant here probably spoke fairly decent English himself, as evidenced by his ability to answer a few initial questions in English. Plus, even though the defense counsel was clearly frustrated by the interpreter's incompetence, it's not like counsel repeatedly objected, or asked for a mistrial, or even asked for a new interpreter. So maybe there's waiver. Or it's no big deal.
On the other hand, there is a state constitutional right to an interpreter in a criminal trial. And it's got to be a competent interpreter. Otherwise you're not getting the rights to which you're entitled. Plus, the interpreter here was so bad that the jury might have viewed the defendant's testimony -- which was riddled with interpreter-induced inconsistencies -- disfavorably, perhaps leading to a conviction in this he-said-she-said credibility contest.
So what do you do?
Justice Yegan writes the majority opinion, and says it's no big deal. The defense didn't do a very good job at objecting. And the jury got to hear the "basics" of Mr. Sokau's defense anyway. So the Court of Appeal's not going to grant relief.
Justice Gilbert dissents. He thinks it is a big deal. That the defendant objected enough and that it's a pretty big deprivation to have your state-provided interpreter totally botch your testimony.
Both sides make decent points.
My own views -- which leave me uncertain -- stem from my internal comparison of the right to a competent interpreter to the right to competent counsel.
Both are in the California Constitution. Both are felt to be essential to a fair trial. The state attempts to satisfy both by appointing people to assist the defendant. Given these similarities, it strikes me as fairly reasonable to maybe apply the same doctrines in one area that we do in the other. And since the "right to competent representation" doctrines are extraordinarily well-developed, I wonder if it might be enlightening to apply these principles to the fairly novel (to me, at least) area of "right to competent interpretation."
If that's right, I'm inclined to be more sympathetic to Justice Gilbert's conclusion. I don't have any doubt that if Mr. Sokau's court-appointed attorney was as terrible as his court-appointed interpreter, the trial court and Court of Appeal would grant him a new trial. And that this would be the result even were it true that the incompetent attorney still got the "basics" across to the jury and even if there was only a halfhearted objection to counsel's ineptitude. If that's the case, why not apply those same principles to incompetent interpreters? Seems like it's pretty important to have the jury actually hear what you're in fact saying, as opposed to some butchered summary coming from the mouth of an inept interpreter. Especially when your life and/or liberty's on the line. The fact that this right is enshrined in the California Constitution only amplifies the point.
Do I think the defense attorney -- or the judge, or even the prosecutor -- should have expressly asked for a mistrial here, or at least (at a minimum) that this incompetent translator get booted? Absolutely.
But I'm not sure that's a bar to relief. Any more than I would think that a defendant's failure to ask that his incompetent attorney get booted should bar him from relief either.
Everyone agrees on the factual underpinnings. Richard Sokau had a terrible interpreter at his trial. A really, really terrible one. The judge knew it; the prosecutor knew it; the defense counsel knew it; and I'm sure everyone in the courtroom knew it as well. I'm not sure how hard it is -- or should be -- for a certified interpreter to translate Palauan (the language of Palau) into English and vice-versa. But the interpreter here failed on nearly every metric.
On that everyone agrees.
But what to do about it?
On the one hand, the defendant here probably spoke fairly decent English himself, as evidenced by his ability to answer a few initial questions in English. Plus, even though the defense counsel was clearly frustrated by the interpreter's incompetence, it's not like counsel repeatedly objected, or asked for a mistrial, or even asked for a new interpreter. So maybe there's waiver. Or it's no big deal.
On the other hand, there is a state constitutional right to an interpreter in a criminal trial. And it's got to be a competent interpreter. Otherwise you're not getting the rights to which you're entitled. Plus, the interpreter here was so bad that the jury might have viewed the defendant's testimony -- which was riddled with interpreter-induced inconsistencies -- disfavorably, perhaps leading to a conviction in this he-said-she-said credibility contest.
So what do you do?
Justice Yegan writes the majority opinion, and says it's no big deal. The defense didn't do a very good job at objecting. And the jury got to hear the "basics" of Mr. Sokau's defense anyway. So the Court of Appeal's not going to grant relief.
Justice Gilbert dissents. He thinks it is a big deal. That the defendant objected enough and that it's a pretty big deprivation to have your state-provided interpreter totally botch your testimony.
Both sides make decent points.
My own views -- which leave me uncertain -- stem from my internal comparison of the right to a competent interpreter to the right to competent counsel.
Both are in the California Constitution. Both are felt to be essential to a fair trial. The state attempts to satisfy both by appointing people to assist the defendant. Given these similarities, it strikes me as fairly reasonable to maybe apply the same doctrines in one area that we do in the other. And since the "right to competent representation" doctrines are extraordinarily well-developed, I wonder if it might be enlightening to apply these principles to the fairly novel (to me, at least) area of "right to competent interpretation."
If that's right, I'm inclined to be more sympathetic to Justice Gilbert's conclusion. I don't have any doubt that if Mr. Sokau's court-appointed attorney was as terrible as his court-appointed interpreter, the trial court and Court of Appeal would grant him a new trial. And that this would be the result even were it true that the incompetent attorney still got the "basics" across to the jury and even if there was only a halfhearted objection to counsel's ineptitude. If that's the case, why not apply those same principles to incompetent interpreters? Seems like it's pretty important to have the jury actually hear what you're in fact saying, as opposed to some butchered summary coming from the mouth of an inept interpreter. Especially when your life and/or liberty's on the line. The fact that this right is enshrined in the California Constitution only amplifies the point.
Do I think the defense attorney -- or the judge, or even the prosecutor -- should have expressly asked for a mistrial here, or at least (at a minimum) that this incompetent translator get booted? Absolutely.
But I'm not sure that's a bar to relief. Any more than I would think that a defendant's failure to ask that his incompetent attorney get booted should bar him from relief either.
People v. Rojas (Cal. Ct. App. - June 22, 2015)
"A Fresno County jury found Benjamin Rojas guilty of sexually abusing his young
stepdaughter . . . . [and] was sentenced to 40 years to life in prison . . . . On or about August 6, 2011, Rojas’ wife awoke in the middle of the night and
found herself alone in bed. After getting up and searching through the house, she located
Rojas in her daughter’s room. He was naked, and her daughter was clothed only from the
waist up. According to the mother’s trial testimony, the child accused Rojas of touching her vaginal area with his fingers. She also said that Rojas had previously molested her 'a
few times.' . . . The jury deliberated for approximately one hour before finding Rojas guilty on all
counts. He was thereafter sentenced to a total of 40 years to life in prison. The sentence
was calculated as follows: As to Count 1, a mandatory term of 15 years to life. As to
Count 2, a mandatory term of 25 years to life, to be served consecutively. The trial court
imposed the middle term of 12 years for Count 3 . . . ."
The Court of Appeal reverses the conviction on Count 2 on ex post facto grounds. Though the prosecution could retry Mr. Rojas again on this count were it to so choose.
We'll see if it does. To say that we're hard core about molestation offenses is an understatement. As demonstrated by the mandatory 40 years to life sentence here.
The Court of Appeal reverses the conviction on Count 2 on ex post facto grounds. Though the prosecution could retry Mr. Rojas again on this count were it to so choose.
We'll see if it does. To say that we're hard core about molestation offenses is an understatement. As demonstrated by the mandatory 40 years to life sentence here.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)