I can't honestly say that I'm interested enough to read the underlying briefs and make sure that my impression of this case is absolutely, positively right. But I can definitely say this: Judge Kleinfeld writes an opinion that I find both entirely persuasive and incredibly equitable. I like it. A lot.
While I respect Judge Morrow (below), I think that Judge Kleinfeld's decision touches my heart -- and instinctive sense of fairness -- a lot more than hers. And seems to have the law behind it as well.
See if you agree.