Mr. Multani has been sentenced to life in prison. But he also has stage IV lung cancer. It's going to kill him, so he would like compassionate release from prison.
The wrinkle is that Mr. Multani has had stage IV lung cancer . . . for 10 years now. It's a specific type of lung cancer with a particular gene profile, so we have treatments for that. Those treatments are not a cure by any means, but they've enabled Mr. Multani to live this long. Eventually they'll fail, of course. But no one knows when.
Do you get compassionate release?
The Court of Appeal and the trial court say: No.
Yes, the cancer metastasized to his brain in 2017. But since then, it's been "perfectly suppressed." He still has symptoms, of course. He has weakness and problems with balance and cognition that require him to use a wheelchair. And, again, at some point, the cancer almost certainly will kill him. Maybe in a month. Maybe in six months. But maybe not for years. Depends on when the gene-targeting drugs stop working.
The Director of Health Care Services for the CDCR recommended that Mr. Multani be granted compassionate relief, but the trial court disagreed. It held that Mr. Multani was not on an “end-of-life trajectory” under Section 1172.2 in light of his prior and expected future treatment. The Court of Appeal affirms.
Tough call either way, IMO.
