There were no published opinions until late yesterday, but this one finally came out.
It's a great opinion for anyone who wants to file frivolous motions or complaints. As active litigators well know, under the Court Reservation System used in Los Angeles and several other counties, you have to reserve a hearing date and then file the underlying motion within three days of that reservation (or some other set number of days in other counties). Failure to do so vacates the hearing. As a result, you've got to have your motion ready (or nearly ready) to file when you reserve your date.
That's usually no problem.
But with sanctions motions under Section 128.5, as you likely know, you've got to give the other side a 21-day safe harbor notice period. You've got to (1) serve the motion on the other side, (2) wait 21 days, and (3) then file the motion.
This is typically no problem; what's usually done if that you prepare your sanctions motion, serve it on the other side with a blank hearing date (because you can't get one yet), and then after the 21 days has expired, you file and serve the motion (again) with the noticed hearing date.
The Court of Appeal, however, holds that this is improper, and reverses the $19,000+ sanction award here. The panel holds that if you leave the hearing date blank in your initial notice copy -- which you're required to do, since you can't get a hearing date -- that's insufficient under Section 128.5, so you can't get sanctions.
The Court of Appeal recognizes, albeit implicitly, that this means that parties can never get sanctions under Section 128.5 in Los Angeles or similar counties. Too bad, it holds. That's what the statute says.
So at least for now, go crazy. You can't be sanctioned. Congratulations.
Ultimately, if this opinion holds, I suspect that Los Angeles and other counties will, in due course, change their CRS system to allow sanctions motions (unlike regular motions) to reserve a hearing date without the requirement of filing the motion within 3 days. Which in turn will mean that you will be able to reserve sanction hearing dates with abandon, and drop them 21 (or 30, or 60) days thereafter. That may make a slight mess of the reservation system, but we'll deal. (It may also result in occasional late-opening hearing dates.)
Until then, though, it'll be a largely sanction-free world. We'll see how that goes.
