Tuesday, November 17, 2026

In re Callie Sanchez (Cal. Ct. App. - Nov. 17, 2026)

The California Constitution states that a criminal defendant is entitled to pretrial release, assuming that sufficient surety is provided (and with some exceptions), unless they are charged with a felony offense "involving acts of violence on another person." (There also has to be clear and convincing evidence of a risk of substantial bodily harm, but that involves a different issue.)

The Court of Appeal holds that selling drugs to someone "involve[s] acts of violence on another person."

That's a somewhat surprising interpretation of the ordinary meaning of those words.

It's undoubtedly true that selling drugs, including but not limited to fentanyl, can sometimes cause death to another person. There are, sadly, lots of things that can cause death, including but not limited to driving, getting in a bathtub, leaving a puddle in the middle of a store aisle, etc.

We nonetheless usually don't think of these things as "acts of violence."

TBD whether the California Supreme Court feels like stepping in on this one.