Wednesday, May 15, 2024

People v. Ellis (Cal. Ct. App. - May 15, 2024)

This opinion by Justice Yegan contains less than 425 words. It is a page and a half long. It doesn't contain a single case citation. The briefs themselves were almost assuredly many multiples of this length -- and likely depth.

The opinion contains eight different alleged reasons for affirming the decision below. All but the last of these consists of but a single sentence. (The final reason is four sentences: That smuggling marijuana in prison is a serious crime.) The longest of these reasons entails 28 words; the shortest, a mere four words.

I would leave dispositions like this one unpublished.

(Understanding, of course, that justices get to decide for themselves whether their opinions allegedly meet the standards for publication established by Rule 8.1105(c), and that different justices sometimes have markedly different subjective tastes in this regard.)

Tuesday, May 14, 2024

D.K. v. Office of Admin. Hrgs. (Cal. Ct. App. - May 14, 2024)

Here are the first three paragraphs of the "Background" section of this opinion:

"D.K. was found incompetent to stand trial (IST) and committed to the Department of State Hospitals (DSH) by the Orange County Superior Court. D.K. is a patient at Napa State Hospital (NSH) and has been diagnosed with “[u]nspecified schizophrenia spectrum and other psychotic disorder.”

After D.K.’s transfer to NSH, DSH filed a petition with the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) for an interim order to compel involuntary medication of D.K. with antipsychotic medication. . . .

Pursuant to section 1370, subdivision (a)(2)(D)(i), an administrative law judge (ALJ) conducted an evidentiary hearing on January 20, 2023."

That's a fair number of acronyms to start out, eh?

The "IST" one seemed particularly unusual. The opinion only uses the acronym three times. Seems like you could just write it out.

But as long as everyone know what you mean, it probably doesn't really matter much.

Friday, May 10, 2024

Bassi v. Bassi (Cal. Ct. App. - May 9, 2024)

You see exceptionally vituperative divorce cases occasionally in the Court of Appeal, though I suspect that most of them get resolved in unpublished opinions. This one, though, gets published.

When I read them, I often think -- as I did here -- "Wow. Just imagine being married to someone for that long, having children and grandchildren with them, being in a highly remunerative and seemingly happy marriage with them for decades and then getting divorced and having your spouse just totally go off the rails with relentless absolutely crazy litigation and abuse." You've gotta be massively surprised when that happens, no?

You can read the whole opinion about how one spouse has to get the other declared a vexatious litigant, obtain a domestic violence restraining order against them, get tens (hundreds?) of thousands of dollars in sanctions, etc. Suffice it to say that one of the spouses did not take the divorce well. At all.

(Not that the other had a field day either, obviously.)

Divorces sometimes bring out the absolute worst in people, sadly.

Wednesday, May 08, 2024

Doe v. Bonta (9th Cir. - May 8, 2024)

There's a lot about this Ninth Circuit opinion that's not surprising at all.

It's a lawsuit brought by some gun owners in California who don't like that the Legislature recently passed a law that says that identifying information about who has a concealed carry permit or who buys various ammunition -- which is already collected by the state and disseminated to a plethora of law enforcement officials -- also gets to be used (though kept confidential) by specific academic centers at UC Davis and Stanford "created to do research on firearm violence, in order to inform policy and assist the legislature in enacting appropriate legislation." Plaintiffs say that violates the Second Amendment.

It's not surprising that someone decided to bring that lawsuit. Some people really like their guns, and some people really don't like any government involvement with them at all. So pretty much anyone would have predicted that once California passed the underlying statute, some gun owner somewhere would sue.

Similarly, it's not surprising that plaintiffs lost. Both in the district court -- on a motion to dismiss -- and in the Ninth Circuit. Without dissent (and even with Judge Bumatay on the panel). There's surely a right to informational privacy at some level, but the biographical information at issue isn't all that intimate, and it's protected from public dissemination anyway, and the text of the Second Amendment only covers the right to bear arms, not to keep the stuff secret from a Legislatively-chosen group of researchers who are helping the Legislature draft policy, particularly when numerous other public officials already have unchallenged access to this same information. You can read more in the Ninth Circuit opinion as to why plaintiffs lose, but, honestly, the result shouldn't surprise anyone. Plaintiffs would lose even in the current Supreme Court; fairly clearly, in my opinion.

The only thing that surprised me, though, was who was suing.

The plaintiffs themselves are John Does. That makes sense; the whole point of their lawsuit is that they don't want to be identified.

I strongly suspected that their counsel would be one of the especially-active public interest groups that commonly take on these types of cases. Either Second-Amendment-specific groups that like to file even the most aggressive litigation or the usual conservative public interest firms.

Nope. The attorneys on this case are from . . . Snell & Wilmer.

Sort of off brand for a regular near-AmLaw100 firm, right? Particularly if it's pro bono. You'd think they'd go for more traditional help-the-needy stuff. Certainly rather than a fairly-clearly-losing Second Amendment fight, I would have thought.

Anyway, that's the only unusual thing here. Otherwise, pretty much how everyone would expect this thing to go. 


Tuesday, May 07, 2024

Naranjo v. Spectrum Security Svcs. (Cal. Supreme Ct. - May 6, 2024)

It's notoriously difficult to explain the different types of mens rea requirements imposed by criminal laws to first-year law students. It's perhaps even more difficult to explain to this audience -- or anyone -- similar mens rea requirements that may be imposed in the civil context; in particular, by civil statutes that impose civil penalties or consequences for "knowing and wilful" misconduct. What exactly does that mean? Does it mean that you've got to know that your conduct is unlawful, notwithstanding the usual principle that ignorance of the law is no excuse? Or does it merely signify that you need to know the factual predicates of what you've done, regardless of your subjective belief that this conduct is lawful?

The short answer is: It depends. On context as well as a boatload of other things.

Which, in truth, is not a particularly helpful answer, I know. But it's the best one we have.

(Or at least the best one that doesn't take up 20,000+ words.)

The California Supreme Court has to wade into all this in deciding this opinion, which holds that, in this particular context, the required mental state of "knowing" is belied by a good faith belief in the legality of one's conduct. The Court makes clear: That's not always the case, by any means. But it unanimously holds that it's true here.

Justice Kruger's discussion three-quarters of the way through the opinion is probably as good as one can get on this issue. It's fuzzy. It depends on context. But, here, the Legislature probably didn't intend to penalize employers for good faith mistakes -- including but not limited to good faith mistakes regarding legality -- for errors made on a wage statement. You can still sue for injunctive relief and fees. But not statutory penalties. Sorry about that, but that's the best way we can harmonize the statute as a whole.

But as for the larger epistemological question of what it means to "know" something: well, for better or worse, we're going to have to leave that one for the philosophy crowd.

Good luck with that.


Thursday, May 02, 2024

Masimo Corp. v. The Vanderpool Law Firm (Cal. Ct. App. - May 2, 2024)

What surprised me most about this opinion was the very last line.

The opinion itself is savage. Savage. It affirms the imposition of $10,000 in discovery sanctions against a law firm -- The Vanderpool Law Firm (in Seal Beach) -- notwithstanding the firm's argument that it can't be sanctioned because it substituted out of the case before the motion to compel was filed.

The opinion is undeniably correct on the merits: Lawyers and law firms can be sanctioned for, as here, the underlying (sanctionable) discovery responses that led to the motion to compel even if they substitute out before the resulting motion is actually filed. 

But the interesting part of the opinion is just how relentless it is in insulting the underlying lawyer, Douglas Vanderpool.

I would literally have to retype the whole thing to impart an accurate impression of just how pervasively the Court of Appeal publicly shames the underlying attorney, who also represents his firm on appeal. But here are some sample quotes, just to give a sense:

"Vanderpool indisputably advised defendants to stonewall Masimo’s discovery efforts not once but twice, the second time after promising to provide substantive answers. As the discovery referee held, and the trial court confirmed, Vanderpool’s precipitate exit from its representation of at least Bauche did not insulate it from these sanctions for its prior discovery misuse."

"At oral argument, Vanderpool proffered another argument, one not mentioned or even alluded to in either of its appellate briefs. This was that the breakdown in the attorney-client relationship – which ultimately caused the firm to substitute out – was responsible for the boilerplate supplemental responses and therefore supplied “substantial justification” for stonewalling discovery. We find it odd that such an important explanation for Vanderpool’s discovery misuse – almost the exclusive explanation at oral argument – should have been reserved for that occasion."

"The [discovery] referee also had a few words to say about Vanderpool’s including a letter from some members of Congress regarding Masimo’s CEO as part of its opposition to the request for sanctions against it, in an effort “inappropriately to prejudice discovery referee and the Court with irrelevant allegations of misconduct[.]” The words were “shameful” and “cannot be tolerated.”"

"In fact, the responses to the document production requests were so boilerplate that the individual responses began “Responding Party objects to this interrogatory . . . .” Only intermittently did these responses refer to a “request for production.”" 

"This court has in the past had occasion to deplore the lack of civility that has flourished in the legal profession in recent decades. . . . Evidently Vanderpool’s principal attorney, Douglas Vanderpool, did not get the memo. We have quoted above from the condescending email he sent to Masimo’s counsel, Robert Ellison, expressing the firm’s refusal to meet and confer. After being served with the moving papers for the motion to compel, Douglas Vanderpool began an email to Ellison with the subject line “You are joking right?” The body of the email continued in the same vein: “In 30 years of practice this may be the stupidest thing I’ve ever seen. Robert is this really why you went to law school? Quit sending us paper. you know we are out of the case so just knock it off and get a life. Otherwise we’re going to be requesting sanctions against your firm for even bothering us with this nonsense.”

"Incivility is the adult equivalent of schoolyard bullying and we will not keep looking the other way when attorneys practice like this. They will be called out and immortalized in the California Appellate Reports."

Wow.

Here's what really got me, though.

I'm going through the opinion, reading all these incredibly bench-slapping lines (of which there are plenty more), and I'm thinking to myself: "Who's writing this thing?" (Unlike in federal court, in the Court of Appeal, the author's always listed on the last line, and I never skip ahead. I like the suspense.)

I have my suspicions, of course. There are some justices who are occasionally/sometimes/often harsher than others, so I'm thinking it's probably one of them.

Then I get to the last line.

Justice Bedsworth.

Whoa.

He was most definitely not one of my initial suspects. Does he feel strongly about various things? Of course. But the type of harshness you see here is not his usual forte.

Four conduct has to really hack off the Court of Appeal to get an opinion like this one, and from a justice like this one, no less.

Hopefully people will learn the underlying lesson. Be civil. Don't write emails like the one described in the opinion.

Or really bad -- and/or embarrassing -- things may well happen to you. Like here.

People v. Flores (Cal. Supreme Ct. - May 2, 2024)

Justice Corrigan authors a powerful opinion that holds that it's not permissible for the police to conduct a Terry stop just because someone's in a high crime area and pretending to tie his shoe behind a car in order to avoid the police, and Justice Evan authors an equally powerful concurrence (joined by a majority of the Court) that highlights the racial implications of a rule that assumes that the "normal" response to a police encounter is to welcome and/or consent to it.

All of which are worthy of incredibly careful consideration.

My only thought upon reading both opinions is that, while the California Supreme Court is unanimous here, my very strong suspicion is that the United States Supreme Court would come out the other way. Likely 6-3.

Wednesday, May 01, 2024

Sacramento Utility Dist. v. Kwan (Cal. Ct. App. - April 30, 2024)

After reading the briefs, I too suspect -- as the trial court found -- that Mr. Kwan did in fact aid and abet the stealing of electricity for a marijuana grow house in Sacramento, notwithstanding the fact that he says that he knew nothing about it and that whomever signed up for utilities there must have stolen his identity.

But I couldn't help but notice that most of the evidence that Justice Robie cites for this proposition would apply to a fairly large swath of society, including but not limited to me.

Justice Robie says:

"Kwan asserted he did not open the account, was the victim of identity theft, and initially stated during pretrial discovery that he had no connection to Sacramento. 

The District produced evidence countering this defense: Kwan’s phone records showed he had called a Sacramento area 916 number numerous times starting in November 2011; Kwan purchased nearly $800 of equipment from a hydroponic store in March 2011 that could be used to grow cannabis; and Kwan received six cash payments totaling $2,500 from December 2011 to August 2012."

Okay, most of us probably haven't bought $800 worth of stuff from a hydroponic store lately. But I bet a fair number of us have called at least one number in the 916 area code sometime in the last year. I know I have. And six cash deposits that total $2500 over a nine-month period seems incredibly common as well, particularly for someone who (like Mr. Kwan) is unemployed and allegedly works odd jobs for people.

Mr. Kwan ultimately gets tagged for a utility bill that's over $27,000. Ouch. Trebled, so that's over $82,000 total. Triple ouch. Plus another $82,000 on top of that for the District's attorney's fees.

(Sextuble ouch?)

It brings to mind a phrase that people used to say when I was in college:

"Don't steal. Don't get caught stealing."

Tuesday, April 30, 2024

Pell v. Nunez (9th Cir. - April 30, 2024)

I readily concede that I know only a tiny bit about what it takes to become an attorney in California if you've graduated from an unaccredited law school. I know that you've got to pass the "baby bar" at some point after your first year -- and then, ultimately, the actual bar exam -- but that's about it.

Today, however, I learned that you apparently have to pass the baby bar within the first 18 months or so of completing your first year of law school. If you do, then you're good to go, and you get credit for all the classes you took in the interim before passing (e.g., your second and third year classes). But if you don't, you only get credit for your first year of classes.

I can somewhat see why that might be the rule. After all, if it took you twenty times to pass the baby bar, maybe we want you to take a few more classes before taking your shot at the actual bar exam.

That said, I'm not really sure that the underlying reasoning applies in situations like the one the Ninth Circuit addresses today.

Douglas Pell attends an unaccredited law school in California, and wants to be a lawyer. He takes the baby bar and passes on his first attempt -- great job. But he didn't take that exam until three years after his first year of law school. He says that his wife's liver transplant and other medical things got in the way.

Which is perhaps eminently plausible. Mr. Pell is 81 years old.

But the State Bar says, tough, you only get credit for your first year, so those 39 credits you earned after the first year don't count. Retake them.

Mr. Pell sues in federal court, loses, and the Ninth Circuit affirms. I've got no complaint with Judge Ikuta's opinion, which seems doctrinally correct. Technically, the State Bar doesn't admit -- or refuse to admit -- anyone to the Bar. Legally, it only makes "recommendations" to the California Supreme Court. Mr. Pell never filed a petition with the California Supreme Court seeking the relief he currently requests. That's fatal to his lawsuit.

Fair enough.

Though I still feel bad for Mr. Pell. He's in his 80s. It's not like he's got infinitely long to retake all those classes. Plus, he passed on his first attempt. No small feat. Seems like the guy's got it fairly together. Even though -- perhaps for understandable reasons -- he couldn't get it together to take his shot at the baby bar within the first 18 months.

Were he to file a petition with the California Supreme Court, and were I on it, I'd probably look fairly sympathetically the thing.

If an 81 year old can finish law school, pass the baby bar, and then pass the actual bar exam, I'm generally more than happy to have the guy as a lawyer. More power to ya.

Good luck, Mr. Pell.

Monday, April 29, 2024

People v. Fay (Cal. Ct. App. - April 29, 2024)

The California Supreme Court should grant review of this Court of Appeal opinion. Even if it's right. Whether you're convicted of murder, and thus spend most or all of the rest of your life in prison, should not depend on which particular appellate panel you happen to draw.

The question presented is the required mental state for a murder conviction when you commit an assault. Let's say, as here, you punch someone in the head in a regular old street fight, and they ultimately die as a result. The evidence suggests that you certainly didn't intend to kill them, but nonetheless that you wanted to punch them somewhere on their body where it would hurt a lot, and didn't particularly think (or care) about whether they might perhaps die as a result of your blows. They weren't blows that would normally cause death, but anything's possible, right?

Is that enough for a murder conviction?

The trial court below told the jury, consistent with what the prosecutor told them in their closing argument, that the standard is not that you didn't care whether the person was killed, but rather "the standard for this charge is[,] I don’t care if someone is hurt or killed, arguing that the defendant was guilty because he "didn't care that Anthony Davis [the victim] was hurt. He didn’t care.” That argument almost certainly made the difference in this case; the jury was repeatedly and completely deadlocked before that argument and instruction, and afterwards, it found the defendant guilty.

Is that an accurate statement of the law?

The trial court thought so, and there's a Court of Appeal opinion -- Olivas -- that said exactly that, albeit in dicta and in the context of an out-of-control driver whose conduct fairly clearly satisfied the typical "conscious disregard for human life" established by the California Supreme Court in Knoller. Moreover, the standard set forth in Olivas -- that the prosecution just has to prove that the defendant thought "I know my conduct is dangerous to others, but I don’t care if someone is hurt or killed" -- has been applied by at least a half-dozen other Court of Appeal opinions, albeit again likely in dictum.

Whether that's an accurate statement of the law seems critical to decide uniformly and statewide. There are lots of people who would be guilty of murder if it's enough that they don't care that someone's "hurt" who definitely wouldn't be guilty of murder if the required showing is that they have to not care that someone may be killed by their actions sufficient to demonstrate a "conscious disregard for human life." And murder -- even second-degree murder -- is a sufficiently serious charge that we definitely want to get the standard right, and not convict someone of murder who wouldn't be guilty of that very serious offense in a different appellate division or in front of a different panel in the Court of Appeal.

So this is one of those cases where the California Supreme Court needs to take the case up and decide once and for all what the right rule should be. Because it's a serious charge with serious disagreement and serious consequences for everyone involved.

Friday, April 26, 2024

People v. Berlin (Cal. Ct. App. - April 26, 2024)

This seems like an easy decision with which to comply -- as long as you're aware of it beforehand.

Can a judge order someone to pretrial mental health diversion? Yes. Of course. Can a judge order restitution? Same answer: Yes. Clearly.

But if you want to order restitution, you've got to do so before the two-year (or whatever) mental health diversion is over and you're about to dismiss the charges.

Not after.

So holds the Court of Appeal, reversing the trial court.

Again: An easy decision to follow, as long as you know of it.

Which now everyone (hopefully) does.

Wednesday, April 24, 2024

Fejes v. FAA (9th Cir. - April 23, 2024)

Given that marijuana is legal in Alaska and that the feds generally don't prosecute the stuff, it seems incredibly harsh to entirely deprive someone of his livelihood -- here, taking away James Feje's private pilot license (he's a bush pilot in Alaska) -- just because he transport weed to rural Alaskan communities that have no roads and no other way to get the stuff.

That said, yeah, the statute does seem to say that your pilot's license can indeed be revoked for flying weed, so if the federal government elects -- in its sage (?) discretion -- to pull your license, there's really nothing the Ninth Circuit can do about it.

Given the underlying statutory predicate, as a lawyer, I might have suggested to Mr. Fejes that he be a little more low-key about his business. At a minimum, maybe expressly calling his company "Flying High Investments" was a mistake.

Monday, April 22, 2024

Ruelas v. County of Alameda (Cal. Supreme Ct. - April 22, 2024)

This opinion of the California Supreme Court -- in response to the Ninth Circuit's certified question -- is unanimous, and reading Justice Evans' opinion, you can potentially see why. She does a very good job of exploring the interplay between the various statutory provisions here, some of which were added by the Legislature and others of which were added by the electorate Proposition 139. Forthrightly, I'm not certain at all that the voters were, in fact, fully "aware" of the way the California treated various prisoners when it passed the underlying initiative (in fact, I'm extremely confident that they weren't), but I understand and appreciate that we pretend that they were when we seek to harmonize various statutory provisions.

I just have one question.

Imagine that you're a lawyer -- as, indeed, most of you are. You, presumably, care a fair piece about justice, in every sense of that word, right?

On your deathbed, are you really excited that your principal contribution to California jurisprudence is making sure that jail inmates who are not convicted of any offense -- e.g., pretrial detainees -- are paid absolutely nothing for the eight hours of work they do every day in the kitchen for a private employer (thereby, coincidentally, taking that job away from someone else) whereas inmates who have been found guilty of a crime are entitled to receive pay equal to that paid to the company's private employees?

That's just, honestly, not something that I think is just, or -- at a minimum -- something that I really want to devote the (increasingly) limited hours of my remaining lifetime to accomplishing.

I say that not to pick on -- at all -- the (winning) counsel for appellants here. The first representative matter he lists on his firm's web site, for example, is a pro bono case that he and others at the firm litigated to "successfully secur[e] compassionate release for a D.C. inmate and military veteran, reuniting him with his family." Well done. I can see why that's something that, on one's deathbed or otherwise, one might be legitimately proud of accomplishing. (I get it if others might disagree, on the theory that the inmate had presumably been convicted of a crime and released before he served his full sentence, but the point is that the end result is consistent with one's own personal values.)

But helping to make sure that innocent inmates (i.e., the presumptively "not guilty") get paid absolutely nothing for their work, whereas guilty inmates get paid? Nah. Everyone, of course, deserves to have an attorney to help them argue their position in court, especially if they happen to be right on the law. 

I'll just let someone else brief and argue that one, thanks.

Maybe there's someone in the world who would defend the proposition that guilty people should get paid for their work in prison but that innocent people shouldn't. Personally, though, I just don't see it.

Regardless, at least until (and if) the law gets changed, that's currently the rule in California.

Thursday, April 18, 2024

U.S. v. Ramirez (9th Cir. - April 18, 2024)

I'm fairly confident that this is all about pretext. But given that the Supreme Court is fine with allowing pretextual traffic stops, my sense is that the police officers here did an admirable job of keeping things calm and respectful. As, I might add, did the defendant.

Here's how the traffic stop went down:

"In July 2020, Officers Dorin Buchanan and Patrick Marshal pulled over Victor Ramirez after witnessing him speed in a residential neighborhood, fail to stop at a stop sign, and not use a turn signal. Before pulling Ramirez over, one of the officers recognized him as a gang member based on an earlier encounter.

After Ramirez stopped his car, Officer Buchanan approached and immediately asked: “What’s up my man? You on probation or parole?” Ramirez answered, “Parole.” Officer Buchanan then asked, “For what?” and Ramirez responded, “For a firearm.”

Officer Buchanan followed up with a few more questions, including when he last checked in with his parole officer, where he lived, whose car he was driving, and what he was doing in the area. During this exchange, Officer Buchanan could see that Ramirez had several gang-related tattoos. And based on those tattoos, Officer Buchanan claimed to know that Ramirez was in an area populated by rival gang members. Officer Buchanan testified that it would be “uncommon” for a rival gang member to be in the area “without a firearm.”

Officer Buchanan instructed Ramirez to turn off the car. He then asked, “You don’t got to reach for it, but do you have a driver’s license?” Ramirez stated he did but that it was not with him. Next, Officer Buchanan asked Ramirez to put his right hand on the back of his head and unbuckle his safety belt with his left hand.

While Ramirez’s right hand was on his head and his left hand was hanging out the car window, Officer Buchanan asked Ramirez if he had a “strap” on him. Ramirez answered, “To be honest with you, I do.” Officer Buchanan responded, “It is, what it is. A man like you is not going to drive through that neighborhood without a strap, you feel me?” Ramirez then informed Officer Buchanan that the gun was in the glove compartment of the car.

Once Ramirez was out of the car, the officers retrieved a loaded 9mm semiautomatic pistol from the glove compartment. Officers also checked the computer system in their patrol car and confirmed that Ramirez was on parole. A federal grand jury indicted Ramirez for possessing a firearm and ammunition as a felon, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1)."

I might add that, in reading the briefs, there were additional details of their interactions that were fully consistent with the underlying conversational tone; e.g., the officer saying "Do me a favor bro, put your right hand on the back of your head for me dude, [and] with your left hand, reach across and take off your seatbelt okay? Thank you, bro. Keep that right hand on the back of your head.”

Bro code, apparently. But well played.

Wednesday, April 17, 2024

Kuigoua v. Dept. of Veterans Affairs (Cal. Ct. App. - April 17, 2024)

I'm not exactly sure why Justice Wiley decided to publish this opinion, since it seems fairly clearly to make no new law and merely holds -- consistent with legions of precedent -- that in employment cases, in which you have to exhaust your administrative remedies first before you can sue, it's not okay to list one set of facts in your administrative petition and an entirely different set of facts in your subsequent lawsuit (e.g., claims for sex discrimination at one location in the administrative petition but claims of sexual harassment at a different location in the lawsuit). Can't do that. Summary judgment.

Granted, there are some new fancy words in the opinion that aren't usually used in your run-of-the-mill employment opinions (e.g., "oppression," "scotched," "conciliate" and the like), plus a new analogy that might perhaps help explain things to some people ("Kuigoua loses this appeal because he changed horses in the middle of the stream. His agency complaint was one animal. On the far bank, however, his lawsuit emerged from the stream a different creature.). But otherwise, it's just a typical application of a set group of established legal principles to the particular facts at issue here.

Not that I particularly care if an author decides to publish an opinion that seems fairly clearly to meet none of the nine alternative standards for publication set forth in Rule 8.1105(c). Maybe a couple of trees take a hit, but otherwise, no real harm done.

Just somewhat unusual.

Tuesday, April 16, 2024

City of Santa Cruz v. Superior Court (Cal. Ct. App. - April 16, 2024)

Two thoughts sprung to my mind when I read this opinion:

(1) What an incredible waste of taxpayer money when a county (here, Santa Cruz County) sues a city (here, the City of Santa Cruz) over whether the city or county is responsible for a public road (here, Capitola Road) that allegedly got undermined by drainage pipes and needed to be repaired. It's a nine-count complaint (!) for $1.2 million in which the County is suing the City for (1) dangerous condition of public property, (2) trespass, (3) nuisance, (4) waste, (5) indemnity and contribution, (6) removal of lateral and “subadjacent” (sic) support, (7) declaratory relief, (8) account stated, and (9) goods and services rendered."

Taxpayers funding lawyers on one side and taxpayers funding on the other side, to be decided by courts funded by taxpayers, including but not limited to the present appeal. The parties can't work this thing out cooperatively? Seriously? Particularly in a lawsuit over a $1.2 million, which is an incredibly small figure in the governmental scheme of things?

(2) What a stupid rule that when a county sues a city, the city's allowed to create its own rule that requires a claim to be initially presented by the country to the city before a lawsuit is filed. Municipal claims rules are likely stupid in their own right -- the claims pretty much always get denied, and it's just another way to make lawsuits against a municipality more difficult and potentially enable a jurisdictional defense even if there's actual liability -- but those rules are especially silly when they apply to claims made by another governmental entity. Who cares if the county just files in court first? It's not like there's a serious concern that there will be too many frivolous intergovernmental lawsuits. Counties should just be able to sue cities if they want. (But should think seriously before doing so -- see Point No. 1.)

Regardless, that's the law.

Monday, April 15, 2024

Perez v. City of Fresno (9th Cir. - April 15, 2024)

Judges Forrest and Thomas disagree on whether the law is "clearly established" that it's not okay for police officers to use continuous force (e.g., by kneeling on someone's back) to someone who's on the ground and handcuffed, particularly when (as here) he is telling the officer that he's unable to breathe.

But can we all at least agree that there are a disturbing number of cases, both in the Ninth Circuit and elsewhere, involving that pretty much identical fact pattern? (FWIW, Judge Thomas' dissent quotes a prior Ninth Circuit opinion that says "The officers—indeed, any reasonable person—should have known that squeezing the breath from a compliant, prone, and handcuffed individual despite his pleas for air involves a degree of force that is greater than reasonable," and says "Between 2003 and 2017, six of our sister circuits reached a similar conclusion concerning use of prone compression on a subject who has been restrained." We all could likely add additional cases that didn't result in opinions in the Court of Appeals.)

At a minimum, we can all at least hope that the number of these cases diminishes in the future, right?

Surely there's got to be at least some common ground.

P.S. - Hat tip to 11-year old Carli, who left us this morning for Dog Heaven. Godspeed.


Friday, April 12, 2024

U.S. v. Medina-Lopez (9th Cir. - April 12, 2023)

That darn Westlaw. Always messing up circuit precedent by placing an unjustified red flag on cases that were not, in fact, overruled.

So sayeth Judge Graber. (Fixing the problem here.)

Thursday, April 11, 2024

People v. Lewis (Cal. Ct. App. - April 10, 2024)

Michael Lewis, age 37, has a lengthy rap sheet, and his latest offense was a first-degree murder conviction (he shot the victim half a dozen times at close range) in August 2022 for which he received a sentence of 75 years to life. During previous periods of incarceration, "Lewis had numerous rules violations, including for fighting, participating in a riot, failing to respond to notices, delaying a peace officer, disobeying orders, battery on a peace officer, and battery with a deadly weapon."

Not someone you'd facially be likely to let out of prison anytime soon, right?

But Mr. Lewis was also recently diagnosed with ALS, and according to the doctors, his particular case is "pretty rapidly progressive.” At the time of his compassionate release hearing in August 2023, the doctor testified that "Lewis is dependent on medical staff to 'do everything for him.' Lewis requires assistance in eating, showering, and using the bathroom. He is able to walk short distances but experiences some weakness in his legs. Because of the lost functionality of his arms, Lewis is 'very unsteady' walking, so he occasionally falls. He fell the week before the hearing. Staff transport Lewis to appointments by wheelchair. Given the rapid progressivity of the disease and Lewis’s weakness, Dr. DiTomas opined: '[T]here’s just no way [Lewis] could cause harm to somebody. You just have to push him a little bit, and he’s going to fall over. There’s no way for him to protect himself.'” The doctor also testified that Mr. Lewis was about to fully lose his ability to speak in about a month, and “would not be surprised if he died in the next six months. And [she] would be surprised if he lived a year." Finally, "Dr. DiTomas observed that during the couple of months that Lewis had been in her unit he had 'been incredibly respectful, appreciative of care,' and the staff supported him."

The trial court denied compassionate release on the grounds that Mr. Lewis was still a serious danger to the community. The Court of Appeal reverses and orders him immediately released.

The original opinion was unpublished, and rendered on January 3, 2024. It was published today. It'd be interesting to find out what Mr. Lewis' condition is today -- I tried a little to find out, but couldn't discover anything online. Sixth months after his hearing in August 2023 was close to the same time the opinion was issued, so I suspect that he lived at least that long. It's now been almost eight months since the hearing, and the doctor said she'd be "surprised" if he lived a year. Presumably he's still alive, and since I can't find any reports of any crimes he's committed, I presume the Court of Appeal is right -- thus far, anyway -- that he's at least not an obvious recidivist at this point.

Lots of people, I suspect, would think that spending only a year in prison for first-degree murder was way less than necessary. Others, I believe, would understand and agree with letting this particular person out to die on his own.

Your call?

Wednesday, April 10, 2024

Casola v. Dexcom (9th Cir. - April 10, 2024)

Everything that Judge Callahan says and does here is exactly right. And -- full disclosure -- I say that even though I have a good friend who is the COO of the losing party.

It's an appeal that's necessitated by a messed-up contemporary filing system in state court -- one that wasn't anticipated by the people who crafted the old-school removal rules during the pre-electronic filing era -- as applied to a common trick that sophisticated parties routinely employ to game the system in a way that Congress didn't anticipate when it, too, crafted the removal rules in a pre-electronic era. So it's basically one set of antiquated rules as applied to another set of antiquated rules; rules that both made sense in the old days, but that lead to abuse nowadays.

Here are the basic underlying rules:

(1) In the old days, you "filed" a lawsuit when you physically handed it to the Clerk. But now, most cases are (and must be) e-filed, typically using service providers, and the case isn't technically "filed" until after the Clerk "processes" the complaint and officially "files" it, which may be several days (or even a week) later.

(2) Both now and in the old days, you've got 30 days to remove a lawsuit from state court to federal court. In the old days, we'd know full well when those 30 days started running: from the filing date (i.e., delivery to the Clerk). But what about in the new days? Does it start ticking upon the e-filing date, or only once the complaint is "accepted" by the Clerk and officially "filed"?

(3) In the old days, you pretty much found out about a lawsuit once you got served with it. But in the new days, most sophisticated corporate parties have services that tell them immediately once a lawsuit has been filed against them, even before service, and -- nowadays -- even in advance of the complaint actually being "accepted and filed" by the Clerk (because they have access to the e-filing records). A party can't remove a lawsuit from its home state in a diversity suit, but there's an exception for parties that are not yet served (because we don't want sham unserved parties to prevent removal). In the new days, can you "snap-remove" a lawsuit -- even from your home state, and even when you're the sole defendant -- as long as you find out about the lawsuit quickly and remove it before the plaintiff has had a chance to serve you yet? Moreover, in the very-new days, can you "super-snap-remove" a lawsuit even before it's been "officially filed" by the Clerk?

There are some other additional complexities addressed in Judge Callahan's opinion; e.g., appellate jurisdiction (or lack thereof) over remand orders, as well as timeliness issues. Regardless, in my view, she answers all of them correctly. Or at least all of them that she needs to.

The Ninth Circuit holds that "super-snap" removals aren't proper. You can't remove a lawsuit from state court before it's "officially" filed; i.e., in the period after it's submitted for e-filing but before it's been "accepted" by the Clerk. Such removals aren't effective; they're void. So back to state court you go.

That all seems right to me, for the exact reasons Judge Callahan articulates. She does a great job both discussing the textual provisions here as well as the equities.

Expressly left unresolved, however, is whether "regular" snap-removal is permissible; i.e., removal after the lawsuit is "accepted" (e.g., one minute after the Clerk electronically issues the summons) but before the lawsuit is officially served.

This, in my view, is where textualism fails. Yes, the statute says that you can remove, even from your home state in a diversity case, if the defendant who resides in that state is not yet served. But that leads to abuse, and conflicts with the core purpose of the statute, which was to stop removal in diversity cases when it wasn't needed because the defendant resides there anyway. So, for someone like me, the proper way to resolve cases like that are to interpret the statute consistent with its clear purpose, and to say that you're only an "unserved" party for purpose of that provision if you're unserved because you're basically a sham party added to prevent removal. Which categorically wouldn't be the case where, as here, you're the ONLY defendant, and the only reason you're not yet served is because you removed the case before the plaintiff even had a practical chance to serve you. Problem solved, IMHO, and justice advanced.

But that's not what textualists -- or other circuits -- have done. To society's detriment, I believe.

But that's an issue for another day. For now, at least, "super" snap removal isn't permitted. And, maybe, one of these days we'll stop "regular" snap removal as well.

Or maybe not.

Regardless, in the meantime, take advantage of the rules, and pay attention to what lawsuits (if any) are filed against you. And promptly remove them before you're served.

Just wait until the thing is actually officially "accepted".

P.S. - I also agreed with Judge Callahan's concluding decision to have both sides bear their own costs. That's entirely equitable as well, I think, given the complexity of the underlying issues. Well done.